Unpredictable and monetized contact with the police: Race, avoidance behaviors, and modified activity spaces

Abstract

Exponential growth in order maintenance policing and associated misdemeanor sanctions have led to disproportionate consequences for people of color. Using data from qualitative interviews with individuals in the metropolitan St. Louis, Missouri, region, the current study documents the racialized and monetized nature of police contact. This work extends extant scholarship by considering how minor contact with the police shapes individual avoidance behaviors and activity spaces, places where people work and live. We consider how the combination of monetary sanctions, warrants, incarceration, and overpolicing in the region affects avoidance behaviors, particularly for people of color. Our findings suggest that the frequently unpredictable nature of police contacts and the parochial and often profit-focused structure of policing organizations in the region leads individuals to modify the ways in which they move through the region and, for some, to isolate. Narratives reflect the need for constant calibration of behaviors and decisions, as well as the legacy that police contact and monetary sanctions can have on everyday routines.

Assessing the Impact of Cannabis Decriminalization on Racial Disparities in Chicago’s Cannabis Possession Arrests

“…Moreover, it is important to note that while tickets are certainly less punitive than arrests, tickets come with a financial burden. While Hispanics and Whites are arrested less frequently than Blacks, tickets with their associated fees may negatively impact them as well (Giuffre and Huebner 2023), particularly if they are disadvantaged. In the swiftly changing landscape of cannabis policy, if cannabis policy is aimed at racial disparities in drug law enforcement, legalization over decriminalization appears to be the appropriate route given the nature of policing, racial bias, and discretionary police actions, as well as the financial burden associated with police contact (Giuffre and Huebner 2023).…”

Reframing the debate on legal financial obligations and crime: How accruing monetary sanctions impacts recidivism

“…Longer and more intensive supervision, in turn, increases the likelihood that technical violations will occur and be detected (Hyatt & Barnes, 2017). Moreover, new evidence documents that these dynamics are likely exacerbated because the presence of LFOs can engender avoidance behaviors with critical social institutions such as schools (Giuffre & Huebner, 2023). Taken together, these dynamics have long-term implications, further entrenching cumulative disadvantage in several domains of life (Kurlychek & Johnson, 2019), and decreasing the possibility of attaining the benefits of key structural goals across the life course (Laub & Sampson, 1993).…”