“…It has been practiced to recover phosphorus from wastewater and/or waste activated sludge (WAS) (Jupp et al, 2021;Liu et al, 2021;Ma and Rosen, 2021), ranging from struvite (Hao et al, 2013) to vivianite (Hao et al, 2022b;Wijdeveld et al, 2022). However, the proper environments suitable for formation of both struvite and vivianite are relatively strict (Hao et al, 2022b(Hao et al, , 2013Prot et al, 2021), and moreover P-recovery efficiencies of struvite and vivianite are not very high, at 15-30% and 40-70%, respectively (Chrispim et al, 2019;van der Kooij et al, 2020;Wijdeveld et al, 2022;Wilfert et al, 2015). In another approach to P-recovery, WAS-incinerated ash (5-10 P% or 11-23 P 2 O 5 %) have a high potential in the P-recovery efficiency, up to 90% (Fang et al, 2020;Jupp et al, 2021;Liu et al, 2021).…”