This review paper examines the relationship between chemicals inducing ewessive accumulation of a2u-globulin (ai21g) (CIGA) in hyline droplets inmale rat kidneys and the subsequent development of nephoit and rnal tubule nopaia in the male rt. This dose-responsive hyaline droplet accumulation distinguishes CIGA carcinogens fromclssical renal carcinogens. CIGA carcinogens also do not appear to react with DNA and are generally negative in short-term tests for genotoxicity. CIGA or their metabolites bind specifically, but reversibly, tomale rat a2,-g The resulting complex appears to be more resistant to hydrolytic degradation in the proximaltubule than native, unbound a2,-g Singlecell necrosis of the tubule epithelium, with associated granular cast formation and papillary mineralization, is followed by sustained regenerative tubule cell prolifertin, foci oftubulehyerl a inthe aovoited pronal bules, and renal tubule tumor Although stnrcturally similar proteins have been detected in other species, including hu_ms, renal lesios characteristic Of a2,-g nephropathy have not been observed. Epidemiologic investigation has not specifically examined the CIGA hypothesis for humans. Based on cancer bioassays, hormone manipulation studies, investigations in an ae,-g-deficient strain of rat, and other laboratory data, an increased proliferative response caused by chemically induced cytotoxicity appears to play a role in the development ofrenal tubule tumors in male rats Thus, it is reasonable to suggest that the renal effects induced in male rats by chemicals causing a2.-g accumulation are unlikely to occur in humans.
IntroductionFor most hazardous chemicals, adequate human data are not available, and risk analyses must rely on information from laboratory studies of rats or mice. The inference that the results ofanimal experiments can be applied to humans is a fundamental principle of all toxicologic research. This analysis deals with a specific case, however, where the male rat seems to respond in a manner different from other laboratory species. The possibility of a unique response in the rat among laboratory animals raises questions about the applicability of the rat data to other species, including humans. Our review evaluates the matter of human 'Medical Research Council relevance and describes the types of information needed for hazard assessment of such chemicals.A variety of organic chemicals have produced specific renal lesions in male rats in the form of a protein (hyaline) droplet nephropathy accompanied by accumulation of a2%-globulin (a2.-g) [reviewed in (1,2)]. Among the chemicals tested are paraffins (3,4), decalin (decahydronaphthalene) (5,6), petroleum-based and synthetic fuels (7), military aviation propellants (8), and 2,2,4-trimethylpentane (TMP) (9). As seen in Table 1, which lists a sampling ofchemicals that have been tested, many are of considerable regulatory and commercial interest. For example, isophorone is a chemical intermediate of major industrial importance. Aviation and automotive fuels fit i...