This research was performed to investigate the optimum conditions for developing pozzolanic ashes from organic wastes to be used as cement replacement materials. The organic wastes explored in the research are rice husk ash (RHA), wheat straw ash (WSA), and cow dung (CDA). When the organic waste is turned into ash, it develops a pozzolanic character due to the presence of silica. However, the presence of reactive silica and its pozzolanic reactivity depends on the calcination temperature, duration, and grinding. In this research, the organic wastes were calcined at three different calcination temperatures (300 °C, 400 °C, and 800 °C) for 2, 4, 6, and 8 h duration. The obtained ashes were ground for 30 min and replaced by 20% with cement. The samples containing ashes were tested for compressive strength, X-ray diffractometry (XRD), weight loss, and strength activity index (SAI). It was observed that the RHA calcinated at 600 °C for 2 h showed better strength. However, in the case of WSA and CDA, the most favorable calcination condition in terms of strength development was obtained at 600 °C for 6 h duration. The highest SAI was achieved for the mortar samples containing CDA calcinated at 600 °C for 6 h duration (CDA600-6H). The other two ashes (RHA and WSA) did not qualify as pozzolan according to the ASTM C618 classification. This was due to the presence of silica in crystalline form and lower surface area of the ash material. In this research, the ash was ground only for 30 min after calcination which did not contribute to an increase in the specific surface area and thus the pozzolanic activity. The materials ground for the higher duration are recommended for higher SAI.