User Preferences for Privacy Protection Methods in Mobile Health Apps: A Mixed-Methods Study

Abstract

Background: Mobile health (mHealth) apps have the potential to facilitate convenient health care delivery and self-management of health. However, many users have concerns about their privacy when they use mHealth apps. Different apps provide different solutions for protecting users’ privacy. Objective: The purpose of this study was to determine user preferences among the several privacy protection methods used in current mHealth apps and the reasons behind their preferences. Methods: Five privacy protection methods currently used in mHealth apps were presented to a group of study participants who had mild or moderate depression and expressed concerns about privacy of information when they used mental health apps. After a demonstration of the methods, study participants were asked to fill out a questionnaire and indicate their perceived privacy protection level (PPPL) of each method, their preference rating for each method, and the privacy protection methods they had used in the past. A brief interview was then conducted to collect study participants’ comments on these methods and elicit the reasons for their preference ratings. Statistical analysis was performed to determine the statistical significance of differences in participants’ preference ratings and in the PPPLs obtained for the five methods. Study participants’ comments on the privacy protection methods and suggestions were noted and summarized. Results: Forty (40) study participants were selected from a large candidate pool using the IRB approved selection criteria. All study participants viewed the app demonstration and understood the five privacy protection methods properly, which was indicated by their correct sorting of the PPPL of the five methods in their answers to the questionnaire. All study participants specified their preferences with respect to these methods and provided the rationale behind their selections on the questionnaire and during the brief interview. The results indicate that the users preferred privacy protection methods with customizable modules in multi-purpose apps because of their convenience and strong privacy protection, where the customization can be done either in the app or via a Web portal. Conclusions: This study identified user preferred privacy protection methods. These identified privacy protection methods may be used in many types of apps that perform sensitive health information management to better protect users’ privacy and encourage more users to adopt these mHealth apps.

People with long-term conditions sharing personal health data via digital health technologies: A scoping review to inform design

“…Users also highlighted that it would be beneficial to selectively grant permissions, for example, granting periods of access to shared data as opposed to unrestricted and the ability to remove permissions to certain parties if and when deemed appropriate. Related to this theme is Hiding Information , referenced by one publication [ 53 ], to avoid accidental disclosure to bystanders who might observe app use—relating to the earlier Fear of Misuse through Theft or Accidental Disclosure theme. It is suggested that parts of apps could be hidden quickly and flexibly so that shared data cannot be seen by third parties.…”

Findings from the 2021 Yearbook Section on Health Information Management

“…Zhou and Parmanto used a mixed methods design to study what users of mobile health apps preferred in terms of privacy protections when using mHealth apps that Findings from the 2021 Yearbook Section on Health Information Management contained sensitive health information [13]. Even though the users may have decided themselves to use the apps, they wanted methods to protect their privacy, not just of the information contained in the apps, but even the fact that they were using the app.…”

Multipurpose Mobile Apps for Mental Health in Chinese App Stores: Content Analysis and Quality Evaluation (Preprint)

“…Additionally, people may refuse to use mHealth apps because of concerns about health data security and privacy [49,50]. Furthermore, concerns about privacy protection are exacerbated by people's sense of shame about using mental health services [51][52][53]. However, the trust between app developers and users may be damaged by the lack of clarity of privacy policies, which results in the loss of potential long-term users [54].…”