User Requirements for a Chronic Kidney Disease Clinical Decision Support Tool to Promote Timely Referral

Abstract

Background Timely referral of patients with CKD has been associated with cost and mortality benefits, but referrals are often done too late in the course of the disease. Clinical decision support (CDS) offers a potential solution, but interventions have failed because they were not designed to support the physician workflow. We sought to identify user requirements for a chronic kidney disease (CKD) CDS system to promote timely referral. Methods We interviewed primary care physicians (PCPs) to identify data needs for a CKD CDS system that would encourage timely referral, and also gathered information about workflow to assess risk factors for progression of CKD. Interviewees were general internists recruited from a network of 14 primary care clinics affiliated with Brigham and Women’s Hospital (BWH). We then performed a qualitative analysis to identify user requirements and system attributes for a CKD CDS system. Results Of the twelve participants, 25% were women, the mean age was 53 (range 37–82), mean years in clinical practice was 27 (range 11–58). We identified 21 user requirements. Seven of these user requirements were related to support for the referral process workflow, including access to pertinent information and support for longitudinal co-management. Six user requirements were relevant to PCP management of CKD, including management of risk factors for progression, interpretation of biomarkers of CKD severity, and diagnosis of the cause of CKD. Finally, eight user requirements addressed user-centered design of CDS, including the need for actionable information, links to guidelines and reference materials, and visualization of trends. Conclusion These 21 user requirements can be used to design an intuitive and usable CDS system with the attributes necessary to promote timely referral.

Awareness and Discussions About Chronic Kidney Disease Among African-Americans with Chronic Kidney Disease and Hypertension: a Mixed Methods Study

“…49 Finally, electronic decision support could help alleviate clinical uncertainty by identifying patients with CKD and facilitating access to patient education tools about CKD during busy primary care encounters. [50][51][52][53] Our study has limitations. First, this was a small study of African-American patients at a single urban primary care clinic, which may limit generalizability to other practice settings or populations.…”

Developing an Ophthalmology Clinical Decision Support System to Identify Patients for Low Vision Rehabilitation

“…Although standardization is the foundation for promoting physician compliance, streamlining clinic flow, and improving system cost-effectiveness, [25][26][27] customization to user requirements including more refined firing criteria by subspecialty may benefit user engagement and sustainability. [28][29][30] Lack of such consideration may result in alert overlook or underutilization of referral.…”

A Pragmatic Cluster Randomized Trial of an Electronic Clinical Decision Support System to Improve Chronic Kidney Disease Management in Primary Care: Design, Rationale, and Implementation Experience

“…Instead, they have utilized standard reminders or checklists. In addition, concerns about the eCDSS being burdensome or disruptive to workflow have hindered the development and testing of more complex, individualized eCDSS [23,30,31].…”