Increased precipitation in the Arctic is a robust feature across model simulations of the coming century, driven by intensification of meridional moisture transport and enhanced local evaporation in the absence of sea ice. These mechanisms are associated with distinct, seasonal, spatial, and, likely, precipitation isotope (δ2HPrecip) expressions. Historical observations of δ2HPrecip reveal a contrast in seasonality between southwestern and northwestern coastal Greenland: δ2HPrecip in northwestern Greenland varies in phase with local temperature, whereas δ2HPrecip in southwestern Greenland is decoupled from local temperature and exhibits little seasonal variation. We test the hypothesis that reduced δ2HPrecip seasonality in southwestern Greenland relative to northwestern Greenland results from dynamic moisture source variations, by diagnosing monthly average moisture sources to three sink regions (Kangilinnguit, Ilulissat, and Qaanaaq) using the Water Accounting Model‐2layers model. All domains demonstrate strong intra‐annual moisture source variations. Moisture to the southernmost region is sourced most remotely in summer and most locally in winter, associated with stronger cooling from the source in summer than winter, promoting more negative δ2HPrecip and counteracting local temperature‐driven seasonality. In comparison, moisture transport distance to the northernmost region is relatively constant, as local sea ice restricts northward migration of the winter moisture source. We simulate seasonal patterns in δ2HPrecip in a simple Rayleigh model, which confirm the importance of source temperature and starting isotopic compositions in determining δ2HPrecip for these regions. δ2HPrecip sensitivity to moisture source variability suggests these coastal Arctic settings may yield paleoclimate records sensitive to the moisture transport processes predicted to amplify future precipitation.