Using Behavior Over Time Graphs to Spur Systems Thinking Among Public Health Practitioners

Abstract

Public health practitioners can use Behavior Over Time (BOT) graphs to spur discussion and systems thinking around complex challenges. Multiple large systems, such as health care, the economy, and education, affect chronic disease rates in the United States. System thinking tools can build public health practitioners’ capacity to understand these systems and collaborate within and across sectors to improve population health. BOT graphs show a variable, or variables (y axis) over time (x axis). Although analyzing trends is not new to public health, drawing BOT graphs, annotating the events and systemic forces that are likely to influence the depicted trends, and then discussing the graphs in a diverse group provides an opportunity for public health practitioners to hear each other’s perspectives and creates a more holistic understanding of the key factors that contribute to a trend. We describe how BOT graphs are used in public health, how they can be used to generate group discussion, and how this process can advance systems-level thinking. Then we describe how BOT graphs were used with groups of maternal and child health (MCH) practitioners and partners (N = 101) during a training session to advance their thinking about MCH challenges. Eighty-six percent of the 84 participants who completed an evaluation agreed or strongly agreed that they would use this BOT graph process to engage stakeholders in their home states and jurisdictions. The BOT graph process we describe can be applied to a variety of public health issues and used by practitioners, stakeholders, and researchers.

Defining and Intervening on Cumulative Environmental Neurodevelopmental Risks: Introducing a Complex Systems Approach

“…Systems science is increasingly being recognized in the health sectors for its utility in mapping and understanding complex health problems, operationalizing research evidence, and systematically analyzing ranges of intervention and policy solutions ( Luke and Stamatakis 2012 ; Atkinson et al. 2015 ; Calancie et al. 2018 ).…”

“…Systems modeling is not new and is routinely used in fields such as corporate management, economics, engineering, physics, biology, and environmental resource management (Sterman 2000;Forrester 1961;Currie et al 2018;Tidwell et al 2004). Systems science is increasingly being recognized in the health sectors for its utility in mapping and understanding complex health problems, operationalizing research evidence, and systematically analyzing ranges of intervention and policy solutions (Luke and Stamatakis 2012;Atkinson et al 2015;Calancie et al 2018). Systems-oriented approaches have been successfully applied to examine trends and the impact of various interventions prior to implementation for specific conditions, such as influenza (Araz 2013), suicide prevention (Atkinson et al 2015), cancer (Marcus 2007), cardiovascular disease (Hirsch 2010;Brittin et al 2015;Knight et al 2017), and diabetes and obesity (Hammond 2009;Hammond and Dube 2012;Luke and Stamatakis 2012;Johnston et al 2014;Zhang et al 2014;Gittelsohn et al 2015;Freebairn et al 2019).…”

Designing for Dissemination and Sustainability to Promote Equitable Impacts on Health

“…Dissemination and sustainability activities are embedded within complex social, health, organizational, and political systems ( 97 , 121 ). Systems science approaches such as systems thinking, systems mapping, system dynamics, and human factors engineering have all been used in D4DS endeavors ( 29 , 136 , 138 , 164 ). These distinct but related approaches help address the interactive and complex adaptive systems issues in dissemination and sustainment.…”

Novel participatory methods for co-building an agent-based model of physical activity with youth

“…Graphs Over Time script. The Graphs Over Time script is a well-established component of group model building in system dynamics that we adapted to understand the typical daily patterns of physical activity of youth [33]. The script engages participants in developing plots of one or more variables that capture how the issue of interest and other relevant factors change over time.…”