Using Constrained Optimization for the Allocation of COVID-19 Vaccines in the Philippines

Abstract

Background Vaccine allocation is a national concern especially for countries such as the Philippines that have limited resources in acquiring COVID-19 vaccines. As such, certain groups are suggested to be prioritized for vaccination to protect the most vulnerable before vaccinating others. Objective The study aims to determine an optimal and equitable allocation of COVID-19 vaccines in the Philippines that will minimize the projected number of additional COVID-19 deaths while satisfying the priority groups for immediate vaccination. Methods In this study, a linear programming model is formulated to determine an allocation of vaccines such that COVID-19 deaths are minimized while the prioritization framework set by the government is satisfied. Data used were collected up to November 2020. Total vaccine supply, vaccine effectiveness, vaccine cost, and projected deaths are analyzed. Results of the model are also compared to other allocation approaches. Results Results of the model show that a vaccine coverage of around 60-70% of the population can be enough for a community with limited supplies, and an increase in vaccine supply is beneficial if the initial coverage is less than the specified target range. Additionally, among the vaccines considered in the study, the one with 89.9% effectiveness and a 183 Philippine peso price per dose projected the lowest number of deaths. Compared with other model variations and common allocation approaches, the model has achieved both an optimal and equitable allocation. Conclusions Having a 100% coverage for vaccination with a 100% effectiveness rate of vaccine is ideal for all countries. However, some countries have limited resources. Therefore, the results of our study can be used by policymakers to determine an optimal and equitable distribution of COVID-19 vaccines for a country/community.

Towards a Unified Pandemic Management Architecture: Survey, Challenges and Future Directions

“…There are several works that utilize a similar optimization formulation that distributes vaccines among communities based on their direct and herd immunity and mortality minimization [57][58][59]. Bertsimas et al proposed a model that combines DELPHI epidemiological model with a bilinear, non-convex optimization to minimize exposure, mortality, and distance between vaccination centers and population centers [60].…”

On Spatiotemporal Overdispersion and Macroparasite Accumulation in Hosts Leading to Aggregation: A Quantitative Framework

“…Whatever the reasons are, we need to consider the variance and the possible “black swans” or the outliers, which could not be detected by only investigating the average dynamics of the host–parasite interaction. This framework of thinking could have an impact on the management of health systems, which also has socio-economic implications [ 37 , 38 ]. Overdispersion and aggregation pose unequal exposure, vulnerability, and risk to hosts.…”

University personnel and students’ perspective on COVID-19 vaccine acceptability

“…As of June 17, 2021, there are 14,205,870 total doses delivered in the Philippines. The government aims to vaccinate 70% of Filipinos in 2021 to acquire herd immunity [25]. As of June 20, 2021, nearly 6.3 million Filipino have already received the first of two doses of the COVID-19 vaccine, representing more than 4% of the country's population and roughly 2.2 million have already received both doses of the vaccine [26].…”