SCS pincer ligands have an interesting combination of strong-field and weak-field donors that is also present in the nitrogenase active site. Here, we explore the electronic structures of iron(II) and iron(III) complexes with such a pincer ligand, bearing a monodentate phosphine, thiolate S donor, amide N donor, ammonia, or CO. The ligand scaffold features a protonresponsive thioamide site, and the protonation state of the ligand greatly influences the reduction potential of iron in the phosphine complex. The N-H bond dissociation free energy can be quantitated as 56 ± 2 kcal/mol. EPR spectroscopy and SQUID magnetometry measurements show that the iron(III) complexes with S and N as the fourth donors have an intermediate spin (S = 3/2) ground state with large zero field splitting, and X-ray absorption spectra show high Fe-S covalency. The Mössbauer spectrum changes drastically with the position of a nearby alkali metal cation in the iron(III) amido complex, and DFT calculations explain this phenomenon through a change between having the doubly-occupied orbital as dz2 or dyz, as the former is more influenced by the nearby positive charge.