Using Mixed Methods to Understand Spatio-Cultural Process in the Informal Settlements: Case Studies from Islamabad, Pakistan

Abstract

A mixed-methods approach is used to understand the human factors defining cultural heritage in two informal settlements in Islamabad, Pakistan, namely France Colony and Mehr Abadi. The methodology applied is based on spatial investigation within a placemaking framework to create a visual representation of the neighborhoods, and grounded theory to explore the experiences and memories of their inhabitants through verbal communication. A combination of techniques, including transect walks, photography, and on-site interviews, allows us to map the tangible and intangible elements of the informal settlements. Cultural characteristics are identified as essential in the spatio-cultural processes occurring in the informal settlements. The study concludes that cultural dilapidation happens because of obstructions in the processes translating intangible heritage into tangible space. Appropriate policy interventions are suggested to minimize the loss of rural heritage transfer to informal settlements within the urban fabric of Islamabad.

Historical Insights into Sustainable Development: Analyzing the Spatiotemporal Dynamics of Ancient Trade and Settlements

“…Qualitative analysis aids in understanding and interpreting the intricate historical contexts and human geographical phenomena, while quantitative analysis provides verifiable time-space data support, enhancing the reliability and precision of our conclusions [22]. The application of this mixed methodology enabled a comprehensive analysis of the intertwining of history and reality and has been widely applied in the fields of cultural heritage conservation [23] and human geography [24].…”

Testing the Informal Development Stages Framework Globally: Exploring Self-Build Densification and Growth in Informal Settlements

“…The morphological approach can also help in developing guidelines for urban policy and adaptive capacity [2]. Since no method is perfect, a practical approach comes from merging multiple methods to build in their qualities and reduce the shortcomings and biases that each process introduces [56].…”