Using self-determination theory to understand and improve recruitment for the Coaching for Healthy Ageing (CHAnGE) trial

Abstract

Background Intervention trials promoting physical activity among older people frequently report low and unrepresentative recruitment. Better understanding of reasons for participation can help improve recruitment. This study explored why participants enrolled in the Coaching for Healthy Ageing (CHAnGE) trial, including how their decision was influenced by recruitment strategies. CHAnGE was a cluster randomised controlled trial testing the effectiveness of a healthy ageing program targeting inactivity and falls. Seventy-two groups of people aged 60+ were recruited from community organisations via informal presentations by the health coaches. Methods We conducted a secondary thematic analysis of interview data from our wider qualitative evaluation in which 32 purposively sampled trial participants took part in semi-structured interviews about their experiences of CHAnGE. Data relating to recruitment and participation were analysed inductively to identify themes, then a coding framework comprising the core constructs from self-determination theory—autonomy, competence and relatedness—was used to explore if and how this theory fit with and helped to explain our data. Results Recruitment presentations promoted the CHAnGE intervention well in terms of addressing value expectations of structured support, different forms of accountability, credibility, achievability and, for some, a potential to enhance social relationships. Participation was motivated by the desire for improved health and decelerated ageing, altruism and curiosity. These factors related strongly to self-determination concepts of autonomy, competence and relatedness, but the intervention’s demonstrated potential to support self-determination needs could be conveyed more effectively. Conclusions Findings suggest that recruitment could have greater reach using: 1. Strengths-based messaging focusing on holistic gains, 2. Participant stories that highlight positive experiences, and 3. Peer support and information sharing to leverage altruism and curiosity. These theory-informed improvements will be used to increase participation in future trials, including people in hard-to-recruit groups. They may also inform other physical activity trials and community programs.

Exploring Korean College of Education Pre-service Teacher Persistence Toward a Teaching Career: Quantitative Analysis of Reasons and Factors for Persisting

“…It is a critical motivation theory in education research in which motivation is based on competence, autonomy, and relatedness, and motivation ranges from intrinsic, for itself, to extrinsic to achieve goals (Kolleck, 2019). SDT also relates altruism to autonomy, competence, and relatedness satisfaction (Haynes et al, 2021). This study focuses on the three motivation factors recognized since the 1960s as effective motivations for preferring a teaching career (Alexander et al, 2020).…”

Engaging in and Sustaining Physical Activity and Exercise: A Descriptive Qualitative Study of Adults 65 Years and Older Using the Self-Determination Theory

“…Over the past two decades, the value and relevance of self-determination theory (SDT, Figure 1) in understanding PA behavior [26] has been underscored, with increasing applications to the health domain, health care, and health behavior intervention research [27][28][29]. SDT, a broad theory of human behavior, conceptualizes how behavior is influenced by personal and contextual motivational factors [30,31].…”

Encouraging Adults Aged 65 and over to Participate in Resistance Training by Linking Them with a Peer: A Pilot Study

“…Most older adults want to live in their own home for as long as possible. To achieve this, they need to maintain their health, be able to complete essential activities of daily living (ADLs) such as showering, toileting, dressing, transfers, and cooking, be able to participate in enjoyable activities, such as social outings, to preserve autonomy, competence, and quality of life [ 1 ]. Staying physically active is important for living independently and maintaining good health and quality of life.…”