Using Stakeholder Perceptions to Inform Future Efforts to Implement Mental Health First Aid Training in China: A Qualitative Study

Abstract

Background: The Mental Health First Aid (MHFA) training program has been widely implemented in many high-income countries. Evidence on the adaptation of this and other similar programs in resource-constrained settings like China is very limited. This study aimed to explore the views of key stakeholders on the implementation issues and contextual factors relevant to the scale-up of MHFA in China.Methods: Informed by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research, five implementation domains of intervention characteristics, characteristics of individuals, contextual adaptation, outer and inner setting, and implementation process were investigated through semi-structured in-depth interviews. Twenty-four stakeholders with diverse expertise in the Chinese mental health system were interviewed. Transcripts were coded using NVivo 12 software and thematically analyzed.Results: Fifteen themes and 52 sub-themes were identified in relation to the five domains. Participants saw MHFA as meeting the need for more evidence-based interventions to improve population mental health. Previous participants in MHFA training were satisfied with the course, but their intentions to help and levels of self-efficacy varied. Contextual adaptation of course content, delivery formats, and financing models, was seen as essential. External health policies and some socioeconomic factors (e.g., improved living conditions) were perceived as potential enablers of scalability. Low levels of engagement in health interventions and lack of supportive social norms were identified as potential barriers while executive support, quality control, and sustainable funding were viewed as facilitators of implementation.Conclusion: MHFA training meets some very important current societal and public health needs in China. To achieve its potential impact, significant contextual adaptation is required, particularly in terms of course content, delivery formats, and financing models. Overcoming low levels of engagement in community-based mental health interventions and combating stigma will also be critical for its scale-up.

Cultural adaptation of the guidelines for offering mental health first aid to a person after a potentially traumatic event: a delphi expert consensus study in Brazil

“…Both groups also endorsed strategies relating to the importance of first aiders working with and providing information to other professionals, perhaps reflecting a clear understanding that the role of the first aider is not to provide ongoing care but rather to provide the initial assistance, a concept that has been unfamiliar in some settings [ 30 ].…”

Mental health first aid training among healthcare French students: a qualitative study

“…Their results highlighted the increased confidence, helping experiences and empathy of the participants as well as a sense of responsibility and more concerns about their own well-being. A qualitative study from China ( 21 ) among previous participants focused on the implementation of MHFA in this country, addressing contextual issues such as adaptation of the content and financing models. Another study from Wales explored the experiences of instructors delivering the training ( 22 ) and underlined the emotional labor experienced by them.…”

Stigmatizing attitudes toward mental disorders among non-mental health nurses in general hospitals of China: a national survey

“…Due to these factors, non-mental health nurses in general hospitals are highly likely to come into contact with PWMD and play an essential role in the timely referral of patients to psychiatrists ( 33 ). However, nurses cannot better provide appropriate assistance to this population because of their negative attitudes toward mental disorders, lack of identification of PWMD, or lack of skills to assist ( 34 , 35 ), which further affects the effective treatment, early diagnosis, and effective referral rate of this group of patients, thereby resulting in more extended hospital stays, and patients with mental problems being more prone to doctor-patient disputes ( 36 ).…”