The intensively studied Si(111)-(5 Â 2)-Au surface is reexamined using reflectance anisotropy spectroscopy and density functional theory simulations. We identify distinctive spectral features relating directly to local structural motifs such as Si honeycomb chains and atomic gold wires that are commonly found on Au-reconstructed vicinal Si(111) surfaces. Optical signatures of chain dimerization, responsible for the observed (Â 2) periodicity, are identified. The optical response, together with STM simulations and first-principles total-energy calculations, exclude the new structure proposed very recently based on the reflection high-energy electron diffraction technique analysis of Abukawa and Nishigaya [Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 036102 (2013)] and provide strong support for the Si honeycomb chain with the triple Au chain model of Erwin et al. [Phys. Rev. B 80, 155409 (2009)]. This is a promising approach for screening possible models of complex anisotropic surface structures. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.087401 PACS numbers: 78.68.+m, 73.20.Àr, 78.20.Bh The Si(111)-(5 Â 2)-Au surface has been the subject of long and intensive experimental and theoretical study, due to its potential for applications in nanoelectronics and its prototypical nature for studying self-assembly and properties of one-dimensional quantum structures [1,2]. On the experimental side, this includes STM [3][4][5], reflection high-energy electron diffraction (RHEED) [6], LEED [7], photoemission [8][9][10], and optical spectroscopy [11,12]; theoretical works generally focus on surface energies, electronic structure, and STM simulations [13][14][15][16]. Nonetheless, its structure remains controversial. Significant inconsistencies arose when even the most promising structures, all of which feature a Si honeycomb chain [17], were compared with experimental data [5].The recalibration in 2009 [18] of the Au coverage from 0.4 monolayers (ML) to 0.6 ML prompted a reevaluation of the Si(111)-(5Â2)-Au atomic structure. In particular, an exhaustive theoretical-experimental study by Erwin-Barke-Himpsel [16] (henceforth, EBH) proposed a three-chain model that largely resolved the remaining discrepancies in the STM and photoemission data [5]. However, a recent RHEED study by Abukawa and Nishigaya [6] (henceforth, AN) predicted a completely new structure, which appears consistent with Y-shaped structures found in STM [3,5]. Most notably, the model does not contain Si honeycomb chains.Independent evaluation of competing structural models is provided by reflectance anisotropy spectroscopy (RAS) [19]. The technique probes both filled and empty surface and interface states while discriminating against the bulk response of cubic materials and hence is particularly sensitive to the local surface and interface atomic structure. Moreover, RAS simulation has now evolved to a level capable of producing impressive agreement with experiment, revealing sensitivity to subtle structural phenomena, such as dimer composition [20] [26] in interface systems. Adsorbaterecon...