Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) is an opportunistic pathogen causing diseases ranging from mild skin infections to life-threatening conditions, including endocarditis, pneumonia, and sepsis. To identify host genes modulating this host-pathogen interaction, we infected 25 Collaborative Cross (CC) mouse strains with methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA USA300) and monitored disease progression for seven days. We identified eight ‘susceptible’ CC strains with high bacterial load, tissue damage, and reduced survival. Among the surviving strains, six with minimal colonization were classified as ‘resistant’, while the remaining six tolerated higher organ colonization (‘tolerant’). The kidney was the most heavily colonized organ, but liver colonization was better correlated with reduced survival. We identified four CC strains with sex differences: females survived the study period while males met our euthanasia criteria earlier. In these CC strains, males had more baseline circulating monocytes and red blood cells. We identified several CC strains that may be useful as new models for endocarditis, myocarditis, pneumonia, and resistance to MRSA infection. Resistant strains had higher pre-infection circulating neutrophils than susceptible and tolerant strains. GM-CSF, IL-1-alpha, IL-15, IL-28, and IL-31 levels increased significantly in tolerant strains after infection. Using RNA seq, we identified two pathways, IL-1 and ERK1/ERK2, as potentially involved in the mechanism of tolerance. QTL analysis identified two significant loci, on Chromosomes 18 and 3, involved in early and late survival after infection. We prioritized Npc1 and Ifi44l genes as the strongest candidates influencing survival using variant analysis and mRNA expression data within these intervals.