Using the CUSUM Test to Control the Proportion of Inadequate Open Biopsies of Musculoskeletal Tumors

Abstract

Background Biopsies of musculoskeletal tumors lead to alterations in treatment in almost 20% of cases. Control charts are useful to ensure that a process is operating at a predetermined level of performance, although their use has not been demonstrated in assessing the adequacy of musculoskeletal biopsies. Questions/purposes We therefore (1) assessed the incidence of and the reasons for inadequate musculoskeletal biopsies when following guidelines for performing the procedure; and (2) implemented a process control chart, the CUSUM test, to monitor the proportion of inadequate biopsies. Methods We prospectively studied 116 incisional biopsies. The biopsy was performed according to 10 rules to (1) minimize contamination in the tissues surrounding the tumor; and (2) improve accuracy. A frozen section was systematically performed to confirm that a representative specimen was obtained. Procedures were considered inadequate if: (1) another biopsy was necessary; (2) the biopsy tract was not appropriately placed; and (3) the treatment provided based on the diagnosis from the biopsy was not appropriate. Results Five (4.3%) of the 116 incisional biopsy procedures were considered failures. Three patients required a second repeat open biopsy and two were considered to receive inappropriate treatment. No alarm was raised by the control chart and the performance was deemed adequate over the monitoring period. Conclusions The proportion of inadequate musculoskeletal open biopsies performed at a referral center was low. Using a statistical process control method to monitor the failures provided a continuous measure of the performance.

Quality control in a training course of off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting surgery

“…The commonly used methods of SPC include the funnel plots and CUSUM method, which has been used in the medical field Since the 1970s, mainly for public health monitoring, surgical quality control, and learning curve analysis. 10 , 11 Funnel plots based on SPC can be used for medical quality control and meta-analyses. 12 , 13 The results are easy to understand and unaffected by sample size differences and confounding factors between groups.…”

Adjunct diagnostic strategies in improving diagnostic yields in image‐guided biopsies of musculoskeletal neoplasms—A cost‐effectiveness analysis

“…Percutaneous image‐guided biopsy is a minimally invasive and targeted approach to tissue sampling with an overall high diagnostic yield. When compared to open surgical biopsy, image‐guided percutaneous biopsy offers similar diagnostic rates 2–32,49 with overall lower morbidity 3,24,25 . However, up to 15% of these procedures are associated with yielding nondiagnostic tissue.…”