Utilization of the Building-Block Approach in Structural Mechanics Research

Abstract

In the last 20 years NASA has worked in collaboration with industry to develop enabling technologies needed to make aircraft safer and more affordable, extend their lifetime, improve their reliability, better understand their behavior, and reduce their weight. To support these efforts, research programs starting with ideas and culminating in full-scale structural testing were conducted at the NASA Langley Research Center. Each program contained development efforts that (a) started with selecting the material system and manufacturing approach; (b) moved on to experimentation and analysis of small samples to characterize the system and quantify behavior in the presence of defects like damage and imperfections; (c) progressed on to examining larger structures to examine buckling behavior, combined loadings, and built-up structures; and (d) finally moved to complicated subcomponents and full-scale components. Each step along the way was supported by detailed analysis, including tool development, to prove that the behavior of these structures was well-understood and predictable. This approach for developing technology became known as the "building-block" approach. In the Advanced Composites Technology Program and the High Speed Research Program the building-block approach was used to develop a true understanding of the response of the structures involved through experimentation and analysis. The philosophy that if the structural response couldn't be accurately predicted, it wasn't really understood, was critical to the progression of these programs. To this end, analytical techniques including closed-form and finite elements were employed and experimentation used to verify assumptions at each step along the way. This paper presents a discussion of the utilization of the building-block approach described previously in structural mechanics research and development programs at NASA Langley Research Center. Specific examples that illustrate the use of this approach are included from recent research and development programs for both subsonic and supersonic transports.

The Influence of Friction Stir Welding Process Idealization on Residual Stress and Distortion Predictions for Future Airframe Assembly Simulations

“…Following the aerospace experimental building block approach [22], a series of coupon level specimens were designed and manufactured for this first phase of simulation technology development and application. Figure 4 illustrates the butt welding coupons, with each coupon having a global length of 240 mm and an assembled width of 150 mm.…”

Manufacturing Process of High Performance–Low Cost Composite Structures for Light Sport Aircrafts

“…Like any aircraft structure, the Halcon 2 project is designed and manufactured under the "Building-Block Approach," known as the Pyramid of Tests [3,4]. This design methodology deals with several questions on the comprehension of new structural concepts that are not still fairly answered.…”

“…Normally, the analysis of singularity details on composite structures, such as ply drop-offs, bolted/fastened/glued joints or edge effects, takes place at the third and fourth levels. At those stages, if a concept or material problem is detected, it is difficult and costly to change the complete design [4].…”

Contribution of Building-block test to discover unexpected failure modes

“…A Detailed guidelines of the Building-Block approach for structural design are provided in the Department of Defense Handbook [2], and many aviation applications have been reported. In NASA, the Building-Block approach was successfully applied for Advanced Composites Technology Program (ACT) and High Speed Research Program (HSR) [3]. For a commercial use, the structural certification process of Boeing-777 is presented in Ref.…”