Data for the kinetics of the swelling of bentonite bars are shown and measurements for the friction factor between the hydrated bars and steel and plastic pipe are given. The results are compared with a previously derived equation for pressure containment. These results demonstrate that the bars produce a hydrated bentonite that has similar or better pressure containment than other bentonite solutions. Bentonite has long been used for the plugging of water wells and these bars have been produced for use in the plugging and abandonment of oil and gas wells.
Introduction
In a previous paper (Towler and Ehlers, 1997) the process for using bentonite (sodium montmorillinite) for plugging wells was described and an equation was derived for calculating the pressure that could be contained by a bentonite plug. The friction factor in this equation was determined from lab measurements. The process for plugging wells with bentonite is already widely used for shallow water wells in a variety of forms (James, 1996 and Wheaton et al. 1994) and has been gaining acceptance for plugging oil and gas wells (Clark and Salsbury, 2003, Idialu et al., 2004). The potential is that plugging wells with bentonite is much cheaper and more reliable than concrete plugs (Clark and Salsbury, 2003). It is claimed to be more reliable because concrete can fail to seal or later crack due to ground movement or tectonic activity. Hydrated bentonite, on the other hand, is deformable and hence self sealing in such circumstances.
However one of the problems with the process is getting the bentonite to the bottom of the hole before it sets up. Simply pouring bentonite granules into the well tends to result in bentonite swelling and bridging soon after it hits the water column. This holds the bentonite at a site above where it needs to be. A solution to this problem is to compress the bentonite into bullet shaped bars using a suitable binder. This retards the hydration kinetics and allows the bentonite to be deposited to the correct plug location before the swelling occurs. In this paper bentonite pellets have been compressed into a bullet shape and then hydrated into a plug for sealing against steel casing. The pressure to dislodge this plug has been measured and used to determine the friction factor between the bentonite and steel.
Literature review
The costs to plug and abandon (P&A) a well can be substantial. Kaiser and Dodson (2008) have recently reviewed the P&A cost trends for the Gulf of Mexico and the average cost to abandon a well there has risen to $178,000 in 2007 up from $107,000 in 2002. The price would have been even higher if not for economies of scale and turn-key operations. Using day rates the cost of well abandonment has peaked at $235,000/well in 2006. The standard procedure for well abandonment has been well documented (Smith, 1993, Kelm and Faul, 1999, Calvert and Smith, 1994). In the oil and gas industry the standard procedure involves setting a cement plug across the perforations and at certain other intervals required to isolate critical zones. This has usually involved the use of a workover rig but recently coiled tubing units have become popular for reducing costs (Barclay et al., 2004, Chong et al., 2000, Tettero et al., 2004).