Utopia, Dystopia, and Sublime Apocalypse in Montana's Church Universal and Triumphant

Abstract

ABSTRACT. The search for a perfected place on earth is rarely easy or forgiving. Utopias and dystopias demonstrate the practical frailties of attempts to build better human associations, whether as literary efforts or in actual, on‐the‐ground experiments. With a proprietary interest in evaluating the dimensions of place making, geographers can lay claim to be frontline critics of efforts that attempt to craft a better world. The catalog of personality cultists, charismatically murderous leaders, and apocalyptic mass death is long. The Church Universal and Triumphant, currently of Paradise Valley, Montana, is examined as the home for twenty‐five years of an ongoing effort to “improve” lives. If its dilemmas and apparent failures are in keeping with the history of past utopian ventures, geographical lessons remain to be learned about the costs of planning for perfection.

The Paradoxical Black Rock City: All Cities Are Mad

“…In a utopian city, there is ample rationalization for cleaning up according to plan, and as Robert Elliott points out, however grandiose in conception, utopia must still be well enough put together physically to reach a point where sewers hardly smell (Elliott ). A vast literature on the shape of utopia starts with Plato's engineering of the Republic and presses onward, with brio, through the Middle Ages (Starrs and Wright ; Bowditch ). Many scholars are of a mind that human interactions are shaped by the place where they transpire, but without getting too deterministic, geographers are unlikely to argue with the statement that place matters.…”

Meetinghouses in the Mormon Mind: Ideology, Architecture, and Turbulent Streams of an Expanding Church*

“…The Eldorado raid involved polygyny and the establishment of a community that was by any reasonable description a cult (Starrs and Wright 2005): the rise of a powerful and charismatic leader, a cordon sanitaire on information flow into the community, a shunning of contact with non-Fms society, a turning over of assets, the evidently deliberate ostracism and expulsion of adolescent men (feared by older male leaders, some were vanquished as so-called lost boys). Through this all would pierce, in April 2008, a single reigning accusation: a girl claiming to be sixteen years old dialed a West Texas domestic violence hotline and in a whispered voice explained that she had been "married" a year or more earlier and had borne the child of a fifty-year-old man, whom she served as a plural wife.…”