Validity of Research-Grade Actigraphy Unit for Measuring Exercise Intensity

Abstract

This study was conducted in a free-living setting to investigate the measurement validity of a research-based actigraph for strolling and jogging, and to provide a reference for actual practice and research. Because inadequate physical activity (PA) or sedentary lifestyle has become the fourth leading risk factor for mortality worldwide, many countries have been vigorously promoting the concept of “active living”, and the public has been investing greater effort into intensifying their PA. Although research-grade actigraphs have been widely applied to evaluate PA in routine environments, the measurement results may not accurately reflect the wearers’ PA. Unlike most relevant research, which is conducted in well-controlled laboratory environments, the present study was implemented in the field to examine the sensitivity and convergent validity of the MicroMini Motionlogger® Actigraph during strolling and jogging. The following results were revealed: (1) Although the exercise movement speed while jogging was significantly faster than that while strolling, the actigraph readings showed no significant difference between strolling and jogging; (2) The actigraph readings were (significantly or nonsignificantly) negatively correlated with metabolic heat and nonsignificantly correlated with movement speeds. Hence, the actigraph validity for measuring PA intensity while strolling and jogging remains debatable.

Physical Activity and the Risk of Hemorrhagic Stroke: A Population-Based Longitudinal Follow-Up Study in Taiwan

“…Similarly, in the present study, we found that <90 min a week of PA reduced HS risk by roughly 25% ( Table 2 ). Although detailed information regarding types and intensities of PA was not included in the KCIS data, previous surveys have shown that about half of Taiwan's residents engage in strolling and brisk walking ( 18 , 19 ). Lower PA times may be perceived as easier goals both to set and to achieve, given that lack of time has been found to be an important barrier to individuals engaging in PA ( 20 ).…”

Empirical Examinations of Effects of Three-Level Green Exercise on Engagement with Nature and Physical Activity

“…The device was worn on each participant’s dominant hand to measure his or her arm activity in a high proportional integral mode [ 42 ]. Generally, actigraphy features excellent validity and reliability [ 43 , 44 , 45 , 46 , 47 ]. Limb activity and energy expenditure: This study employed the IDEEA 3 (MiniSun LLC, Fresno, CA, USA) to measure the participants’ limb activity and energy expenditure.…”

Wearable technologies for active living and rehabilitation: Current research challenges and future opportunities

“…In general, there is reasonable intra-class correlation for wearable devices, 49 though there are limitations that have been highlighted in a number of recent studies. For example, one study noted that readings did not correlate with intensity of exercise, 50 and another noted that recorded steps for some wearables fell to zero for speeds of 0.3–0.5 m/s. 51…”