The usual derivation of classical nucleation theory is inappropriate for crystal nucleation. In particular, it leads to a seriously flawed estimate of the pressure inside a critical nucleus. This has consequences for the prediction of possible metastable phases during the nucleation process. In this paper, we reanalyze the theory for crystal nucleation based on the thermodynamics of small crystals suspended in a liquid, due to Mullins (J. Chem. Phys. 1984Phys. , 81, 1436. As an illustration of the difference between the classical picture and the present approach, we consider a numerical study of crystal nucleation in binary mixtures of hard spherical colloids with a size ratio of 1:10. The stable crystal phase of this system can be either dense or expanded. We find that, in the vicinity of the solid-solid critical point where the crystallites are highly compressible, small crystal nuclei are less dense than large nuclei. This phenomenon cannot be accounted for by either classical nucleation theory or by the Gibbsian droplet model.The experimental determination of crystal nucleation rates is one of the prime sources of information on the free energy of solid-liquid interfaces (see, e.g., ref 2). The link between the observable quantity (number of crystal nuclei formed per unit time per unit volume) and the surface free energy is usually given by classical nucleation theory (CNT). CNT contains two ingredients: the first is a thermodynamic estimate of the reversible work needed to make a critical nucleus (i.e., a nucleus that is equally likely to dissolve as it is to grow to macroscopic size). This reversible work defines the free energy of a critical nucleus. A system that contains a critical nucleus is at a local free-energy maximum. This is important for what follows, because it means that the free energy is invariant under infinitesimal exchanges of mass or volume between the nucleus and the parent phase. In particular, it means that chemical potentials of all species are constant throughout the system. 3 The second ingredient of CNT is an estimate of the rate at which critical nuclei transform into macroscopic crystallites. In what follows, we focus on the equilibrium properties of critical crystal nuclei.According to CNT, the free energy of a spherical nucleus that forms in a supersaturated solution contains two terms. The first term accounts for the fact that the solid phase is more stable than the liquid. This term is negative and proportional to the volume of the nucleus. The second term is a surface term. It describes the free energy needed to create a solid/liquid interface. This term is positive and proportional to the surface area of the nucleus. The (Gibbs) free energy of a spherical nucleus of radius R has the following form:where F s is the number density of the bulk solid, ∆µ the difference in chemical potential between the solid and the liquid, and γ is the solid/liquid surface free energy density. The function ∆G has a maximum at R ) 2γ/(F s |∆µ|) and the corresponding height of the nucleation b...