Vaping Disparities at the Intersection of Gender Identity and Race/Ethnicity in a Population-Based Sample of Adolescents

Abstract

Background Transgender adolescents use vape products (e.g., e-cigarettes) at higher rates than cisgender adolescents. Little is known about how these disparities differ from the intersectional perspective of both gender identity and race/ethnicity. Methods We examined disparities in past 30-day vaping frequency at the intersection of gender identity and race/ethnicity among adolescents participating in two pooled waves of the population-based California Healthy Kids Survey (N=953,445; 2017-19). Generalized linear mixed models included gender identity-by-race/ethnicity interactions and adjusted for potential confounders. Stratified models quantified relationships between gender identity and vaping within race/ethnicity strata and between race/ethnicity and vaping within gender identity strata. Results Transgender adolescents of color were more likely to report a higher frequency of vaping than cisgender white adolescents. In models stratified by race/ethnicity, transgender adolescents evidenced greater odds of more frequent vaping than cisgender adolescents of the same race/ethnicity; disparities were greatest between transgender and cisgender Black adolescents (adjusted odds ratio [AOR]: 6.05, 95% CI: 4.76–7.68) and smallest between transgender and cisgender white adolescents (AOR: 1.20, 95% CI: 1.06–1.35). In models stratified by gender identity, disparities were greatest between transgender Black and transgender white adolescents (AOR: 2.85, 95% CI: 2.20–3.70) and smallest between transgender multiracial and white adolescents (AOR: 1.28, 95% CI: 1.05–1.58). Similar, though less consistent, patterns emerged for adolescents of color unsure of their gender identity relative to cisgender white adolescents. Conclusion Transgender adolescents of color may be especially vulnerable to vaping disparities. Future research should identify and intervene on causal mechanisms undergirding disparities. Implications Research finds that transgender adolescents use vape products at higher rates than their cisgender peers, however, little is known about how patterns of adolescent vaping may differ by both gender identity and race/ethnicity–information needed to inform culturally-tailored prevention and control initiatives to decrease adolescent vaping disparities. Our analysis of data from a population-based adolescent health survey finds evidence of magnified disparities in vaping frequency among transgender adolescents of color.

A Machine Learning Approach Reveals Distinct Predictors of Vaping Dependence for Adolescent Daily and Non-Daily Vapers in the COVID-19 Era

“…It is worth mentioning that only 0.4% of our cohort did not disclose their race; as such, further studies are required to confirm the robustness of this finding. Still, these results are consistent with prior studies that demonstrated high perceived discrimination by youth to be associated with not only increased uptake of vaping but more frequent use as well [8,52]. Policies promoting cultural diversity, social inclusion, and integration coupled with incident recording and monitoring might mitigate discrimination and its consequences among adolescents.…”

An examination of the social perceptions and vaping preferences of young electronic nicotine delivery system users

“…Although the vaping literature provides some knowledge on differences among vapers by gender or tobacco use status, there are two important gaps in this literature. First, the extent of the relationship between ENDS use, gender, and tobacco in the literature is confined to prevalence (32,33). Some studies have examined the odds of exposure to and engagement of youth to vaping-related content in social media but did not assess gender differences (34).…”

Intersectionality and adolescent medicine: an overview

“…Recent findings show that transgender adolescents of color are more likely to report higher frequency of vaping compared with cisgender white adolescents. Black transgender adolescents specifically, had six times the odds of more frequent vaping relative to their cisgender Black peers and nearly three times the odds of more frequent vaping relative to their transgender white peers [10 ▪ ]. Another study demonstrated that lesbian girls of color had a higher relative risk ratio of current e-cigarette use compared with both heterosexual girls of color and lesbian White girls.…”