Variability of the coupling of blood flow and oxygen metabolism responses in the brain: a problem for interpreting BOLD studies but potentially a new window on the underlying neural activity

Abstract

Recent studies from our group and others using quantitative fMRI methods have found that variations of the coupling ratio of blood flow (CBF) and oxygen metabolism (CMRO2) responses to a stimulus have a strong effect on the BOLD response. Across a number of studies an empirical pattern is emerging in the way CBF and CMRO2 changes are coupled to neural activation: if the stimulus is modulated to create a stronger response (e.g., increasing stimulus contrast), CBF is modulated more than CMRO2; on the other hand, if the brain state is altered such that the response to the same stimulus is increased (e.g., modulating attention, adaptation, or excitability), CMRO2 is modulated more than CBF. Because CBF and CMRO2 changes conflict in producing BOLD signal changes, this finding has an important implication for conventional BOLD-fMRI studies: the BOLD response exaggerates the effects of stimulus variation but is only weakly sensitive to modulations of the brain state that alter the response to a standard stimulus. A speculative hypothesis is that variability of the coupling ratio of the CBF and CMRO2 responses reflects different proportions of inhibitory and excitatory evoked activity, potentially providing a new window on neural activity in the human brain.

Neural and Hemodynamic Responses to Optogenetic and Sensory Stimulation in the Rat Somatosensory Cortex

“…One caveat of this approach is the variability of coupling between the activity-induced cerebral metabolic rate and the increase of CBF. 32 Because CBF and cerebral metabolic rate have opposing effects on the dHb content, the interpretation of dHb amplitude changes is not straightforward. These considerations may explain our findings that the dHb peak had weaker correlation with LFP ( Figure 6e).…”

Uniting adolescent neuroimaging and treatment research: Recommendations in pursuit of improved integration

“…Two modalities, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and functional MRI (fMRI) (Buxton et al, 2014), are excellent for use with youth, as they are non-invasive and offer high-resolution localization.…”

Improving estimates of the cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen from optical imaging data

“…First, as recently proposed by Buxton et al (2014), the CBF and CMRO 2 responses may be affected in different ways by excitatory and inhibitory neural activity. For example, increasing stimulus intensity is likely to increase both excitatory and inhibitory activity; however, if inhibitory activity has a stronger effect on increasing the CBF response than the CMRO 2 response, then increases in stimulus intensity would lead to increases in the coupling ratio.…”