Allergic disease prevalence has significantly increased in recent decades. Primary prevention efforts are being guided by the study of the exposome, or collective environmental exposures beginning during the prenatal period, to identify modifiable factors that impact allergic disease risk. In this review, we explore the evidence supporting a relationship between key components of the external exposome in the prenatal and early-life periods and their impact on atopy development, focused on microbial, allergen, and air pollution exposures. The abundance and diversity of microbial exposures during the first months and years of life have been linked with risk of allergic sensitization and disease. Indoor environmental allergen exposure during early life may also impact disease development, depending on the allergen type, dose, and timing of exposure. Recent evidence supports the role of ambient air pollution in allergic disease inception. The lack of clarity in the literature surrounding the relationship between environment and atopy reflects the complex interplay between cumulative environmental factors and genetic susceptibility, such that no one factor dictates disease development in all individuals. Understanding the impact of the summation of environmental exposures throughout a child's development is needed to identify cost-effective interventions that reduce atopy risk in children.