Variation in surface texture measurements

Abstract

Surface texture influences cellular response to implants, implant wear, and fixation, yet measurement and reporting of surface texture can be confusing and ambiguous. Seven specimens of widely different surface textures were submitted to three internationally renowned laboratories for surface texture characterization. The specimens were from dental implants, orthopedic implants, and femoral heads. Areas to be measured were clearly marked; simplified instructions were supplied but specific measurement parameters were not requested. Techniques used included contact profilometry, two- and three-dimensional laser profilometry, and atomic force microscopy. Four to thirteen parameters were reported, 2D or 3D, including R(a) or S(a); only three were common to all centers. The results varied by as much as +/-300-1000%, depending on technique and surface type. Some surfaces were not measurable by some techniques. One dental implant surface was reported with R(a) of 0.17, 0.85, 1.9, and 4.4 microm. The CoCr femoral head ranged from an R(a) of 0.011 to 0.10 microm; the zirconia head from 0.006 to 0.05 microm. Similar variability was reported for the other parameters. Useful surface texture characterization requires reporting of all measurement parameters. Comparisons between studies may be compromised if differences in technique are not considered.

Surface properties of titanium and zirconia dental implant materials and their effect on bacterial adhesion

“…Ra was calculated for each sample ''Ra: is the arithmetic mean of the absolute values of the surface point departures from the mean plane within the sampling area''. 16 Topographic inspection was conducted using scanning electron microscopy (SEM).…”

Relative influence of surface topography and surface chemistry on cell response to bone implant materials. Part 2: Biological aspects

“…In general, the amplitude parameters (R a , R t , R z ) are commonly considered but the frequency and hybrid parameters are more rarely quantified [50]. It should be noted that the current authors compute more than 100 roughness parameters and then statistically correlate these parameters with biological parameters in order to determine the surface parameter(s) to which the cells respond.…”

The influence of different acids etch on dental implants titanium surface

“…Ra measurement was calculated for each sample: Ra: -is the arithmetic mean of the absolute values of the surface point departures from the mean plane within the sampling area‖ 16 (Macdonald et al, 2004 After verification of the normal distribution and the homogeneity of the variance, an analysis of the variance (ANOVA) was used to asses any significant differences among selected group. For multiple comparisons test (Post Hoc multiple comparisons) LSD (least significant difference) was used to determine the specific differences between the means of the group members.…”