Variations in patient-reported physical health between cardiac and musculoskeletal diseases: systematic review and meta-analysis of population-based studies

Abstract

Population-based assessments of physical health are important to evaluate healthcare resource allocation. Normative data on the level of physical impairments attributable to specific diseases and severity levels within these diseases is critical to interpreting such data. Our objective, by means of a systematic review and meta-analysis, was to test the hypothesis that specific diseases which form cardiovascular and musculoskeletal disease spectra are associated with gradients of physical impairments. We examined a cardiovascular disease spectrum which consisted of hypertension, ischaemic heart disease and heart failure, and a musculoskeletal disease spectrum of lower back pain, osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis. Using Medline, EMBASE and CINAHL databases, articles which had examined these morbidities and used either the SF-12 or SF-36 in general or primary care populations were selected; data was extracted independently by three reviewers. Study characteristics were described and the mean physical component summary scores of the SF-12 or SF-36 was analysed by disease, using random-effects meta-analysis. The association between disease and physical health (mean physical component summary scores) was assessed using multilevel meta-regression analysis, adjusting for age, health setting, country, disease definition and SF-12 or 36 format. From this search, 26 articles were identified, yielding 70 separate estimates of mean physical component summary scores across the morbidities from 14 different countries. For the selected conditions, pooled unadjusted mean physical component summary scores were: 44.4 for hypertension, 38.9 for ischaemic heart disease, 35.9 for heart failure, 39.5 for lower back pain, 36.0 for osteoarthritis and 36.5 for rheumatoid arthritis. The adjusted meta-regression showed mean physical component summary score difference for ischaemic heart disease of −4.6 (95 % confidence interval −6.0 to −3.2) and heart failure −7.5 (−9.1 to −5.9) compared to the hypertension category. For osteoarthritis −4.2 (−5.3 to −3.0) and rheumatoid arthritis −3.9 (−9.5 to 1.6) compared to the lower back pain category. Our findings provide the benchmark norms for the differences in physical health within and between disease spectra. Improved characterisation of the relative impact of individual conditions on physical health will facilitate public health assessments of chronic diseases as well as assessments of interventions using functional patient-reported outcomes.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12955-015-0265-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Peer-support interventions for women with cardiovascular disease: protocol for synthesising the literature using an evidence map

“…22 Individuals 43–70 years with IHD report worse physical HRQoL (38.9 (95% CI 36.9 to 41.0)) compared with the general population. 23 Similar results are reported in women with obstructive (41.9, SD 8.9) and non-obstructive heart disease (43.7, SD 9.4) (p=0.072). 24 Moreover, a decline in physical vs mental HRQoL is more predictive of hospital readmission 25 and mortality in healthy middle-aged and older women (n=40 337) 26 and in men and women with heart disease.…”

Economic and Humanistic Burden of Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review of Large Sample Studies

“…Constant pain greatly affects physical and mental functioning, contributing to decreased quality of life. A previous review of population-based quality-of-life studies found that the HRQoL of OA remained one of the worst compared with other chronic conditions [44,45]. The estimated SF-12 scores for OA from the studies included in our review were better than those summarized in previous reviews [45] but still remain relatively low and comparable to that of breast cancer patients [46].…”

Validation of the VEINES-QOL quality of life instrument in venous leg ulcers: repeatability and validity study embedded in a randomised clinical trial

“…The poor quality of life of these venous leg ulcer patients is shown by their mean SF-12 physical component score of 38.4. For comparison, a review of SF-12 and SF-36 scores in cardiovascular disease [ 22 ] reported the mean physical component to be 44.4 in hypertension patients, 38.9 in ischaemic heart disease, and 35.9 in heart failure, so these patients had similar physical quality of life to patients with ischaemic heart disease. For mental quality of life, our participants’ mean score was 49.6, very similar to 50 in the standard population.…”