Variations in the quality of tuberculosis care in urban India: A cross-sectional, standardized patient study in two cities

Abstract

BackgroundIndia has the highest burden of tuberculosis (TB). Although most patients with TB in India seek care from the private sector, there is limited evidence on quality of TB care or its correlates. Following our validation study on the standardized patient (SP) method for TB, we utilized SPs to examine quality of adult TB care among health providers with different qualifications in 2 Indian cities.Methods and findingsDuring 2014–2017, pilot programs engaged the private health sector to improve TB management in Mumbai and Patna. Nested within these projects, to obtain representative, baseline measures of quality of TB care at the city level, we recruited 24 adults to be SPs. They were trained to portray 4 TB “case scenarios” representing various stages of disease and diagnostic progression. Between November 2014 and August 2015, the SPs visited representatively sampled private providers stratified by qualification: (1) allopathic providers with Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery (MBBS) degrees or higher and (2) non-MBBS providers with alternative medicine, minimal, or no qualifications.Our main outcome was case-specific correct management benchmarked against the Standards for TB Care in India (STCI). Using ANOVA, we assessed variation in correct management and quality outcomes across (a) cities, (b) qualifications, and (c) case scenarios. Additionally, 2 micro-experiments identified sources of variation: first, quality in the presence of diagnostic test results certainty and second, provider consistency for different patients presenting the same case.A total of 2,652 SP–provider interactions across 1,203 health facilities were analyzed. Based on our sampling strategy and after removing 50 micro-experiment interactions, 2,602 interactions were weighted for city-representative interpretation. After weighting, the 473 Patna providers receiving SPs represent 3,179 eligible providers in Patna; in Mumbai, the 730 providers represent 7,115 eligible providers. Correct management was observed in 959 out of 2,602 interactions (37%; 35% weighted; 95% CI 32%–37%), primarily from referrals and ordering chest X-rays (CXRs). Unnecessary medicines were given to nearly all SPs, and antibiotic use was common. Anti-TB drugs were prescribed in 118 interactions (4.5%; 5% weighted), of which 45 were given in the case in which such treatment is considered correct management.MBBS and more qualified providers had higher odds of correctly managing cases than non-MBBS providers (odds ratio [OR] 2.80; 95% CI 2.05–3.82; p < 0.0001). Mumbai non-MBBS providers had higher odds of correct management than non-MBBS in Patna (OR 1.79; 95% CI 1.06–3.03), and MBBS providers’ quality of care did not vary between cities (OR 1.15; 95% CI 0.79–1.68; p = 0.4642). In the micro-experiments, improving diagnostic certainty had a positive effect on correct management but not across all quality dimensions. Also, providers delivered idiosyncratically consistent care, repeating all observed actions, including mistakes, approximately 75% of the time. Th...

High urban tuberculosis case notification rates can be misleading: evidence from an urban setting in Ethiopia

“…However, disaggregating the data about TB cases by place of residence offset the high CNR in urban and low CNR in adjacent communities, which could give the real picture of TB case notification in the areas. Like other studies in urban populations [19][20][21], studies from Ethiopia show that the urban population, representing only 8% of the country's population, contributed 11% of the total TB cases notified [22]. This phenomenon could be due to patients coming from neighboring catchment areas for access to better diagnostics and availability of technical expertise, thereby increasing urban poverty, overcrowding, urban migration, HIV infection, and disease transmission [9].…”

Is enhancing the professionalism of healthcare providers critical to tackling antimicrobial resistance in low- and middle-income countries?

“…The implicit and critical assumption behind this strategy is that qualified HCPs will prescribe or dispense antibiotics responsibly and that directing patients towards qualified HCPs, and away from unqualified HCPs, will reduce inappropriate use of antimicrobials [15]. However, when HCP professionalism is lacking, boundaries between qualified HCPs and unqualified providers can be blurred [17,18]; for example, qualified providers may routinely fail to follow treatment guidelines [19] or regulations around prescribing [20], and informal providers may demonstrate more empathy towards patients than qualified HCPs [17,21]. We therefore hypothesise that weaknesses in the professionalism of HCPs-including doctors, pharmacists, and nurses-will have an impact on inappropriate use of antibiotics, and we investigate this in two LMIC, Pakistan and Cambodia.…”

Building a tuberculosis-free world: The Lancet Commission on tuberculosis

“…Moreover, referral links to the National Tuberculosis Programme are weak, with data from standardised patient studies in these three countries showing that only 28% to 45% of patients were correctly managed by primary care providers. 34,35,46 Simply put, the global capacity to diagnose, link to care, treat, and cure patients with tuberculosis is woefully inadequate for the massive burden of disease that exists. The public health implications, as well as the poor clinical and financial implications for patients, 41 are self-evident.…”

“…Unfortunately, cascade of care analyses shows large gaps in the quality of care for both adults and children, and for both drug-susceptible and drug-resistant tuberculosis in many high-burden countries. [36][37][38]112,133 Standardised patient studies in India, Kenya, South Africa, and China [33][34][35]46 have shown that the quality of care for tuberculosis is poor. In a study in China, for example, health-care providers did not correctly manage patients presenting with archetypal symptoms or results suggesting active tuberculosis 59% of the time.…”