We investigated the usage of two silica nanomaterials (surface-modified) and alkali in enhanced oil recovery through Amott spontaneous imbibition tests, interfacial tension (IFT) measurements, and phase behavior. We evaluated the wettability alteration induced by the synergy between nanomaterials and alkali. Moreover, numerical analysis of the results was carried out using inverse Bond number and capillary diffusion coefficient. Evaluations included the use of Berea and Keuper outcrop material, crude oil with different total acid numbers (TAN), and Na2CO3 as alkaline agent. Data showed that nanomaterials can reduce the IFT, with surface charge playing an important role in this process. In synergy with alkali, the use of nanomaterials led to low-stable IFT values. This effect was also seen in the phase behavior tests, where brine/oil systems with lower IFT exhibited better emulsification. Nanomaterials’ contribution to the phase behavior was mainly the stabilization of the emulsion middle phase. The influence of TAN number on the IFT and phase behavior was prominent especially when combined with alkali. Amott spontaneous imbibition resulted in additional oil recovery ranging from 4% to 50% above the baseline, which was confirmed by inverse Bond number analysis. High recoveries were achieved using alkali and nanomaterials; these values were attributed to wettability alteration that accelerated the imbibition kinetics as seen in capillary diffusion coefficient analysis.