The temperature-dependent hydration structure of long-chain fatty acids and alcohols at air−water interfaces has great significance in the fundamental interactions underlying ice nucleation in the atmosphere. We present an integrated theoretical and experimental study of the temperature-dependent vibrational structure and electric field character of the immediate hydration shells of fatty alcohol and acid headgroups. We use a combination of surface-sensitive infrared reflection−absorption spectroscopy (IRRAS), surface potentiometry, and ab initio molecular dynamics simulations to elucidate detailed molecular structures of the octadecanoic acid and octadecanol (stearic acid and stearyl alcohol) headgroup hydration shells at room temperature and near freezing. In experiments, the alcohol at high surface concentration exhibits the largest surface potential; yet we observe a strengthening of the hydrogen-bonding for the solvating water molecules near freezing for both the alcohol and the fatty acid IRRAS experiments. Results reveal that the hydration shells for both compounds screen their polar headgroup dipole moments reducing the surface potential at low surface coverages; at higher surface coverage, the polar headgroups become dehydrated, which reduces the screening, correlating to higher observed surface potential values. Lowering the temperature promotes tighter chain packing and an increase in surface potential. IRRAS reveals that the intra-and intermolecular vibrational coupling mechanisms are highly sensitive to changes in temperature. We find that intramolecular coupling dominates the vibrational relaxation pathways for interfacial water determined by comparing the H 2 O and the HOD spectra. Using ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) calculations on cluster systems of propanol + 6H 2 O and propionic acid + 10H 2 O, a spectral decomposition scheme was used to correlate the OH stretching motion with the IRRAS spectral features, revealing the effects of intra-and intermolecular coupling on the spectra. Spectra calculated with AIMD reproduce the red shift and increase in intensity observed in experimental spectra corresponding to the OH stretching region of the first solvation shell. These findings suggest that intra-and intermolecular vibrational couplings strongly impact the OH stretching region at fatty acid and fatty alcohol water interfaces. Overall, results are consistent with ice templating behavior for both the fatty acid and the alcohol, yet the surface potential signature is strongest for the fatty alcohol. These findings develop a better understanding of the complex surface potential and spectral signatures involved in ice templating.