Crystal structures have been determined for trimethylboron, BMe 3 , and for a new polymorph of trimethylgallium, GaMe 3 ; in addition, the crystal structure of trimethylthallium, TlMe 3 , has been redetermined. The BMe 3 crystal structure represents a new structural type for the group 13 trimethyl derivatives in the solid state. In contrast to its heavier analogues, it consists of layers containing only very weakly interacting BMe 3 molecules. GaMe 3 forms a ladder-like pseudo-polymer via long gallium-to-methyl intermolecular interactions with Ga‚‚‚C distances in the range 3.096(3)-3.226(4) Å. This is compared with a recently reported crystal structure of a polymorph, which, like InMe 3 and TlMe 3 , is characterized by the formation of pseudo-tetramers. The effects of crystallization and secondary interactions have been analyzed by comparison with related crystallographic, gas-phase electron diffraction, and spectroscopic studies of these and other trimethyl derivatives of the group 13 elements. The energetic differences between polymorphs of BMe 3 , GaMe 3 , and InMe 3 have been explored by plane wave DFT calculations. The energy differences between the BMe 3 -like layered structure and the InMe 3 -like pseudo-tetrameric structure are calculated to be -1.7, +3.6, and +10.4 kJ mol -1 for BMe 3 , GaMe 3 , and InMe 3 , respectively.
IntroductionThere are three different structures that are observed for the group 13 trimethyl derivatives in the crystalline state. One is the dimeric form observed for trimethylaluminum, 1 in which methyl groups participate in strong metal-metal bridges, with C-Al interaction distances commensurate with those of terminal Al-C bonds. Methyl bridging is also observed in a second structural type featured by the derivatives with Ga, In, and Tl, but the interaction distances are substantially longer than the primary metal-carbon bonds. Prior to this study, crystal structures had been determined for GaMe 3 , 2 InMe 3 , 3,4 and TlMe 3 ; 5 here we describe crystal structure determinations of a new polymorph of GaMe 3 and a redetermination of the structure of TlMe 3 . The third structural type is represented by BMe 3 . As we show below, this crystal structure consists of layers in which the molecules interact by weak van der Waals, or possibly electrostatic, interactions. The longstanding debate over the nature and geometry of the bridging methyl groups in Al 2 Me 6 has recently been resolved in a neutron powder diffraction study at 4.5 K, 6 and in this paper we limit our attention to the second and third structural types.We have also investigated theoretically the energetic differences between polymorphs of BMe 3 , GaMe 3 , and InMe 3 in which the molecules form layers (as in the observed structure of BMe 3 ) or weak methyl bridges (as in InMe 3 ). Polymorphism has been described as the supramolecular equivalent of molecular isomerism. 7 Traditional ab initio modeling procedures (notably GAUSSIAN) simulate isolated molecules, but while this style of calculation is suitable for studying gaseous...