"Victims" and "Survivors": Emerging Vocabularies of Motive for "Battered Women Who Stay"*

Abstract

This paper reviews the literature providing reasons for why battered women “stay” in abusive relationships and examines the emergence of images of battered women as “survivors” in early and contemporary activists’ discourses, drawing on ideas from social constructionist approaches to social problems, identity, and deviance to explore this phenomenon. Most of the early representations of battered women I analyze emphasize their emotionality and their victimization, while the more recent constructions of this collective identity discussed here emphasize their rationality and their agency. Both “victim” and “survivor” typifications provide accounts for why battered women stay in violent relationships, thus providing a vocabulary of motive for this oft‐imputed “deviance.” Constructing battered women as survivors, however, may also remediate some of the stigma that can attach to victimization more generally. After situating victim and survivor discourses and considering how the image of a survivor may meet normative expectations that a victim image perhaps violates, I briefly discuss some implications of these alternate collective identities.

Contesting the Dominant Discourse of Child Sexual Abuse: Sexual Subjects, Agency, and Ethics

“…The survivor position offers a better sense of agency, but that agency is built around the specific experience of sexual abuse. Such positioning as survivor, in turn, reproduces the centrality of the incident of CSA in one's sense of self throughout their lives (Dunn 2005;Nielsen 2016;Warner 2001). By refusing to take up these positions, Hardi's subjectivity is not confined to these limited ways of seeing himself as a sexual subject.…”

Pequeñas conquistas en la adversidad: posibilidades de agencia de mujeres que usan la violencia en Buenos Aires y trabajadoras sexuales en la frontera sur de México

“…De los individuos que encarnan esta representación, se esperará, entonces, cierta conducta, forma de expresarse y sentirse. Entonces, en tanto víctimas, las mujeres reciben la solidaridad y la simpatía social, pero también denotan una visión de la mujer inherentemente vulnerable, pasiva y con poca o nula capacidad de agencia y resistencia (Dunn, 2005;Dunn y Powell, 2007: 978). Mohanty (1991Mohanty ( , 2003 expuso cómo en el discurso académico feminista occidental las mujeres del "tercer mundo" han sido representadas como víctimas manifiestas de la ideología y sistema patriarcal.…”

Infrapolitics of Defiance: Forms of Agency Exhibited by Homeless Survivors of Gender-Based Violence

“…This concept is embedded within a public discourse that often portrays women who have experienced IPV as either 'victims' or 'survivors' (Dunn 2005;Naples 2003;Samelius et al 2014). This type of discourse essentializes women's experiences in ways that reinforce the dominant binary between an overemphasis on women's vulnerability on the one hand, or a dismissal of the very real hazards they face on the other.…”