“…This conclusion is in agreement with the other two works, by Bero and Plazek10 and by Meng and Simon,12 in which retardation spectra for the bulk and shear responses were compared. Although the conclusion is inconsistent with Leaderman's suggestion1 that bulk and shear responses arise from different underlying molecular mechanisms, it is consistent with the majority of the literature,2, 4–6, 10, 12 as pointed out in the introduction: the bulk response is generally found to be narrower than the shear response and to occur at shorter times scales (i.e., the midpoint of the bulk and shear dispersions are shifted in time), similar to our results here. However, without comparison of the retardation spectra, these observations were often previously interpreted, incorrectly we argue, to indicate differences in the molecular origin of the two responses.…”