Visual analytics in cheminformatics: user-supervised descriptor selection for QSAR methods

Abstract

BackgroundThe design of QSAR/QSPR models is a challenging problem, where the selection of the most relevant descriptors constitutes a key step of the process. Several feature selection methods that address this step are concentrated on statistical associations among descriptors and target properties, whereas the chemical knowledge is left out of the analysis. For this reason, the interpretability and generality of the QSAR/QSPR models obtained by these feature selection methods are drastically affected. Therefore, an approach for integrating domain expert’s knowledge in the selection process is needed for increase the confidence in the final set of descriptors.ResultsIn this paper a software tool, which we named Visual and Interactive DEscriptor ANalysis (VIDEAN), that combines statistical methods with interactive visualizations for choosing a set of descriptors for predicting a target property is proposed. Domain expertise can be added to the feature selection process by means of an interactive visual exploration of data, and aided by statistical tools and metrics based on information theory. Coordinated visual representations are presented for capturing different relationships and interactions among descriptors, target properties and candidate subsets of descriptors. The competencies of the proposed software were assessed through different scenarios. These scenarios reveal how an expert can use this tool to choose one subset of descriptors from a group of candidate subsets or how to modify existing descriptor subsets and even incorporate new descriptors according to his or her own knowledge of the target property.ConclusionsThe reported experiences showed the suitability of our software for selecting sets of descriptors with low cardinality, high interpretability, low redundancy and high statistical performance in a visual exploratory way. Therefore, it is possible to conclude that the resulting tool allows the integration of a chemist’s expertise in the descriptor selection process with a low cognitive effort in contrast with the alternative of using an ad-hoc manual analysis of the selected descriptors.Graphical abstractVIDEAN allows the visual analysis of candidate subsets of descriptors for QSAR/QSPR. In the two panels on the top, users can interactively explore numerical correlations as well as co-occurrences in the candidate subsets through two interactive graphs.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13321-015-0092-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

molSimplify: A toolkit for automating discovery in inorganic chemistry

“…To accelerate discovery in inorganic chemistry, both flexible generation of 3D structures and efficient first‐principles calculations to evaluate properties are necessary. In organic chemistry, molecular screening benefits from tools that have been developed to store and analyze chemical structures and connectivity, facilitating rapid property evaluation based on connectivity or generation of 3D structures from these descriptions . Within the first‐principles community, OpenBabel and Avogadro provide users access to these rapid structure generation tools in a user‐friendly graphical user interface (GUI).…”

Descriptors and their selection methods in QSAR analysis: paradigm for drug design

“…Thus, expert knowledge in the selection process is required to gain user confidence in the selected set of descriptors. Recently, Martínez et al developed a tool named Visual and Interactive DEscriptor ANalysis (VIDEAN) that combines statistical methods with interactive visualizations for choosing a set of descriptors [37]. They used the expertise of chemists in an interactive visual exploration of different pieces of data generated from statistical and information theory-based metrics.…”

Open source molecular modeling

“…VIDEAN (visual and interactive descriptor analysis) [89] is a visual tool for iteratively choosing a subset of descriptors appropriate for predicting a target property with the aid of statistical methods.…”