Visual Rating and ROI-Based Parametric Analysis of rCBF SPECT in Patients with Mild or Questionable Dementia: A Comparative Study

Abstract

Background: The aim of this study was to assess the accuracy of visual image rating as compared to parametric analysis of regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) measured with SPECT in patients referred to a memory clinic for diagnostic evaluation of cognitive symptoms. Methods: SPECT with ^99mTc-HMPAO was used to determine rCBF in 47 patients and 26 healthy control subjects. The 47 patients (30 F/17 M) had a mean age of 74.6 years (range = 62–88) and mild or questionable dementia with an MMSE score of 24.8 (range = 20–30). Two experienced image readers blinded to the classifications and identity of subjects performed visual rating in consensus and the global and regional CBF patterns were evaluated and graded according to severity of hypoperfusion. Correlation coefficients were calculated using results from the parametric analyses as gold standard. Results: The sensitivity and specificity of global visual rating (normal vs. abnormal SPECT) was 92 and 86%, respectively, yielding an overall accuracy of 89% for visual rating compared to parametric analysis. The correlation between visual rating and parametric analysis was highly significant (p < 0.001). Conclusion: Visual rating is a valid method for analyzing SPECT images in patients with mild or questionable dementia.

A visual rating scale for cingulate island sign on 18F-FDG-PET to differentiate dementia with Lewy bodies and Alzheimer's disease

“…Of interest, a dichotomous visual interpretation of CIS (present or absent) had a higher diagnostic accuracy compared to the quantitative CIS ratio in distinguishing DLB patients from AD patients [21]. However, there are no established visual criteria for the degree of CIS, even though visual rating of other imaging biomarkers and modalities are commonly used and has proven to be a fast, reliable and reproducible method in clinical practice [14,36,37]. The application of a standardized method to classify and interpret the presence of CIS may enhance the utilization of relevant diagnostic information, along with improving the diagnostic accuracy of DLB.…”

99mTc Hexamethyl-Propylene-Aminoxime Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography Prediction of Conversion From Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer Disease

“…The accuracy of visual SPECT ratings to predict AD in patients with MCI has not been evaluated in longitudinal studies (Table 1), even though SPECT visual diagnostic reads are commonly used for this purpose. In a cross-sectional study of patients with MCI and comparison subjects, Hogh (17) reported an overall accuracy rate of 89% in comparing dichotomous visual versus ROI ratings of SPECT abnormality.…”

Combining Structural Brain Changes Improves the Prediction of Alzheimer’s Disease and Mild Cognitive Impairment

“…AD prediction with a higher accuracy may be achieved, although typically in well established disease and when neuropsychological and clinical assessments are also taken into consideration, which can be over a decade behind the detectable structural MRI changes [31]. In general, volumetric measures and visual rating have each been used evaluating neuroimaging, particular MRI, although inter-study variations exist with either technique [32–35]. Consistent with previous studies, our data showed a medium-high predictive value with the use of MTAS [4,28,36].…”