Vitamin and steroid supplementation such as oxandrolone are commonly given to speed the recovery process in severe burn injuries. Vitamin A is administered concurrently with steroids because of its pro-inflammatory and positive effects on wound healing. However, vitamin A supplementation warrants caution as hypercalcemia can result from vitamin A overdose. Our case involves an 18-year-old male injured in an oil field explosion who presented with 55% total body surface area partial and full thickness burns. Following successful resuscitation, he was given vitamin A, oxandrolone, vitamin C, and zinc sulfate as part of the standard vitamin supplementation. On hospital day 33, serum calcium levels were noted to be elevated and increased to 13 mg/dL a few days later. Parathyroid hormone and vitamin D levels were found to be within normal range, and urine analysis showed normal calcium excretion. Subsequent assessment of vitamin A levels revealed significantly elevated levels at 93 mcg/dL. Vitamin A supplementation was discontinued, and the patient was discharged on hospital day 42. At the one-month follow-up, serum calcium levels were normal, which links the hypercalcemia to vitamin A overdose. This case highlights the importance of considering vitamin A overdose as a cause for asymptomatic hypercalcemia with a normal parathyroid and vitamin D workup. While routine, vitamin A supplementation in burn patients calls for assessment of both serum calcium and vitamin A levels throughout the hospital stay to prevent hypercalcemia and its negative effects.