Volume measurement variability in three-dimensional high-frequency ultrasound images of murine liver metastases

Abstract

The identification and quantification of tumour volume measurement variability is imperative for proper study design of longitudinal non-invasive imaging of pre-clinical mouse models of cancer. Measurement variability will dictate the minimum detectable volume change, which in turn influences the scheduling of imaging sessions and the interpretation of observed changes in tumour volume. In this paper, variability is quantified for tumour volume measurements from 3D high-frequency ultrasound images of murine liver metastases. Experimental B16F1 liver metastases were analysed in different size ranges including less than 1 mm3, 1-4 mm3, 4-8 mm3 and 8-70 mm3. The intra- and inter-observer repeatability was high over a large range of tumour volumes, but the coefficients of variation (COV) varied over the volume ranges. The minimum and maximum intra-observer COV were 4% and 14% for the 1-4 mm3 and <1 mm3 tumours, respectively. For tumour volumes measured by segmenting parallel planes, the maximum inter-slice distance that maintained acceptable measurement variability increased from 100 to 600 microm as tumour volume increased. Comparison of free breathing versus ventilated animals demonstrated that respiratory motion did not significantly change the measured volume. These results enable design of more efficient imaging studies by using the measured variability to estimate the time required to observe a significant change in tumour volume.

Three-Dimensional Imaging and Quantification of Both Solitary Cells and Metastases in Whole Mouse Liver by Magnetic Resonance Imaging

“…The advantages and limitations of these modalities, including positron emission tomography, single-photon emission computed tomography, computed tomography, magnetic resonance (MR), ultrasound, and bioluminescent and fluorescent optical imaging, are well documented (9)(10)(11)(12)(13)(14). To date, the majority of studies focusing specifically on solitary metastatic cells have relied on fluorescent optical imaging due primarily to the high-resolution capabilities of this modality.…”

Ovarian Volume Measurements in Mice With High-Resolution Ultrasonography

“…The same trend has been reported in clinical imaging studies because repeated measurements by the same person are more likely to agree than measurements by different individuals. 16,17 Two-dimensional ultrasonographic volume measurements revealed several serious drawbacks based on the use of ellipsoid approximations of ovaries that do not always have regular geometric shapes. The choice of which of the 3 chords is to be used to measure the height, width, and length in a given set of images is not clear-cut and is largely dependent on observer preference, leading to high intraobserver variability in volume estimates.…”

Ultrasound Biomicroscopy in Small Animal Research: Applications in Molecular and Preclinical Imaging

“…This application in experimental medicine can be useful in the detection of xenograft tumors in mice and in longitudinal growth. A set of consecutive 2D image planes of the tumor are acquired then reconstructed into 3D views for tumor estimation analysis [17, 18]. …”