Waiting for the wave: Political leadership, policy windows, and alcohol policy change in Ireland

Abstract

Existing research has identified numerous barriers to the adoption of public health policies for alcohol, including the cross-cutting nature of the policy problem and industry influence. Recent developments in Ireland suggest that while formidable, such barriers can be overcome. Ireland's 2018 alcohol legislation adopts key evidence-based measures, introducing pricing, availability and marketing regulations that are world-leading in public health terms. Drawing primarily on the Multiple Streams Approach (MSA), this study investigates the adoption of the Public Health (Alcohol) Act 2018. We draw data from 20 semi-structured interviews with politicians, government advisors, public health experts, and advocates, as well as from relevant primary documents, newspaper articles, and other material in the public domain. We find that increased public attention to alcohol-related harms in Ireland (problem stream), developments within the institutional location of policymaking (the policy stream), and the political pressure exerted by politicians and advocates (the political stream) all combined to open a policy window. Unlike previous alcohol policy reform efforts in Ireland, several personally committed and well-positioned leaders championed policy change. This study suggests that political leadership might be important in understanding why public health approaches to alcohol have been embraced in some contexts but not in others.

Do Changes to the Alcohol Retail Environment Reduce Interpersonal Violence?

“…Even with all the evidence that has accumulated, attempts to change the alcohol retail environment to impact violence (and alcohol consumption more generally) have often been ineffective. While it is true that the alcohol industry plays no small role in these failures [69,70,71], there is also a more widespread lack of understanding of the alcohol environment as a public health issue [72]. As epidemiologists, how can we contribute to the push for change?…”

The tension between national consistency and jurisdictional professional expansion: The case of pharmacist-administered vaccinations

“…It was used to guide the data analysis for this study, due to the study focus on current policy options for pharmacist-administered vaccinations, and the potential for active policy change towards a nationally consistent approach. This framework was first described by Kingdon in 1984 and has been used extensively in policy research to analyse health areas such as drug and alcohol policy 21 , 22 and obesity prevention policy. 23 , 24 …”

Visuomenės Sveikatos Koalicija Alkoholio Politikos Įgyvendinimo Procese 2007–2011 Metais

“…Taip teoretikai aiškina advokacijų koalicijų "evoliucionavimą" (Sabatier, Weible, 2019;Weible, Nohrstedt, 2012). Pastebėtina ir tai, kad kitose Vakarų šalyse VSK panašiai plėtė ir stiprino koaliciją (empiriniai tyrimai atskleidžia, kad nedominuojančios politinės jėgos gali pasinaudoti politinės kaitos momentais ir išplėsti ar sustiprinti koalicijas) (Lesch, McCambridge, 2021;Thom ir kt., 2016;Hawkins, Holden, 2014).…”