Wargaming for International Relations research

Abstract

Political scientists are increasingly integrating wargames into their research. Either by fielding original games or by leveraging archival wargame materials, researchers can study rare events or topics where evidence is difficult to observe. However, scholars have little guidance on how to apply this novel methodological approach to political science research. This article evaluates how political scientists can use wargames as a method of scholarly inquiry and sets out to establish a research agenda for wargaming in International Relations. We first differentiate wargames from other methodological approaches and highlight their ecological validity. We then chart out how researchers can build and run their own games or draw from archival wargames for theory development and testing. In doing so, we explain how researchers can navigate issues of recruitment, bias, validity, and generalizability when using wargames for research, and identify ways to evaluate the potential benefits and pitfalls of wargames as a tool of inquiry. We argue that wargames offer unique opportunities for political scientists to study decision-making processes both in and beyond the International Relations subfield.

Wargame of Drones: Remotely Piloted Aircraft and Crisis Escalation

“…Because wargames are interactive events that simulate realistic scenarios, they offer a reasonable proxy to study real-world military operations (Lin-Greenberg et al 2022). Just as wargames provide governments with a tool to prepare decisionmakers for crises, they also provide researchers with a unique data source.…”

Crossing a Virtual Divide: Wargaming as a Remote Teaching Tool

“…Wargames are immersive simulations used for two broad purposes: analysis and pedagogy (Goldblum, Reddie, and Reinhardt 2019;Lin-Greenberg, Pauly, and Schneider 2021). Historically, wargames of both types have been played across the US defense establishment and academia (Pauly 2018;Perla and McGrady 2011, 113;Schechter, Schneider, and Shaffer 2021, 514).…”

Evidence of the unthinkable: Experimental wargaming at the nuclear threshold

“…As Pauly notes, one of the major assets of wargaming in comparison with survey experiments is the degree to which participants are 'immersed' in the strategic environment of the game (Pauly, 2018). While still an abstraction of reality, wargames provide a rich environment for insight into human decisionmaking, where a wide range of potential scenarios and conflict dynamics can be captured for analysis (Lin-Greenberg, Pauly & Schneider, 2022).…”