In this research work, designing and fabrication of hybrid epoxy polymer composite materials had been carried out. It consists of basalt fiber (constant fraction) and marble dust particulates (0–10 wt% @ step of 2.5%) ensuing five compositions namely, MBE-0, MBE-2.5, MBE-5, MBE-7.5, and MBE-10. The specimen’s undergone physical, mechanical, and thermo-mechanical characterizations followed by three-body abrasive wear performance evaluation. Parametric optimizations of the wear have been evaluated with the Taguchi technique. The performance data are used to rank the compositions using a hybrid AHP-VIKOR selection making tool. It has been observed that voids content improves with reinforcement up to 5 wt% marble dust reinforcement, thereafter, it deteriorates sharply. The mechanical properties with 5 wt% marble dust reinforcement found to be highest. The thermo-mechanical characteristics like modulus and damping improve with marble dust reinforcement and temperature. The Cole-Cole plots reveal the heterogeneity present in the composites. The Taguchi’s analysis reveals the order of operating factors influencing specific wear rate as abrading distance > normal load > reinforcement composition > abrasive size. The steady state-specific wear rate of the composites reveals decremented rate across the abrading distance range irrespective of reinforcement proportions and at any specific abrading distance the order it followed as MBE-5 < MBE-7.5 < MBE-2.5 < MBE-10 < MBE-0. The ranking analysis using hybrid AHP-VIKOR technique predicts the ranking sequence as MBE-5 > MBE-7.5 > MBE-2.5 > MBE-10 > MBE-0, which are in-line with subjective analysis.