‘We don't tell people what to do’: ethical practice and Indigenous health promotion

Abstract

Health promotion aspires to work in empowering, participatory ways, with the goal of supporting people to increase control over their health. However, buried in this goal is an ethical tension: while increasing people's autonomy, health promotion also imposes a particular, health promotion-sanctioned version of what is good. This tension positions practitioners precariously, where the ethos of empowerment risks increasing health promotion's paternalistic control over people, rather than people's control over their own health. Herein we argue that this ethical tension is amplified in Indigenous Australia, where colonial processes of control over Indigenous lands, lives and cultures are indistinguishable from contemporary health promotion 'interventions'. Moreover, the potential stigmatisation produced in any paternalistic acts 'done for their own good' cannot be assumed to have evaporated within the self-proclaimed 'empowering' narratives of health promotion. This issue's guest editor's call for health promotion to engage 'with politics and with philosophical ideas about the state and the citizen' is particularly relevant in an Indigenous Australian context. Indigenous Australians continue to experience health promotion as a moral project of control through intervention, which contradicts health promotion's central goal of empowerment. Therefore, Indigenous health promotion is an invaluable site for discussion and analysis of health promotion's broader ethical tensions. Given the persistent and alarming Indigenous health inequalities, this paper calls for systematic ethical reflection in order to redress health promotion's general failure to reduce health inequalities experienced by Indigenous Australians.

Identity management strategies among HIV-positive Colombian gay men in London

“…Researchers and advocates from voluntary and statutory agencies need to be wary of the potentially disempowering elements of paternalistic models of support and individualistic models of both identity (i.e. as largely being seen as a 'property' of the individual) and behaviour change (McPhail-Bell et al 2016). Although it has as yet been little researched in relation to Latin American men living with HIV, a greater understanding of project and resistance identities through which members of marginalised communities collectively take action to counter stigma and discrimination, and facilitating the creation and maintenance of socio-political resources that foster such identities is key to tackling compound manifestations of prejudice (Aggleton, Parker, and Maluwa 2003).…”

An evaluation of the ‘Yaka Ŋarali’’ Tackling Indigenous Smoking program in East Arnhem Land: Yolŋu people and their connection to ŋarali’

“…Support for Aboriginal/Yolŋu Health Workers to quit smoking is an urgent priority and help should be offered in ways that are respectful and culturally appropriate . Yolŋu health workers are the first line of contact in health clinics, and therefore play an important role in the delivery of smoking cessation.…”

Voices behind the Statistics: A Systematic Literature Review of the Lived Experience of Rheumatic Heart Disease

“…A systemic impact of colonialism upon Indigenous Australian's health is that Indigenous people are continually positioned as the problem [17]. Postcolonialism seeks to decolonise, to disrupt dominant Western views by privileging the Indigenous voices previously silenced by dominant ideologies [18].…”