Wedge Resection Margin Distances and Residual Adenocarcinoma in Lobectomy Specimens

Abstract

We studied 31 T1 N0 M0 peripheral adenocarcinomas diagnosed by wedge resection and treated by lobectomy. Factors recorded were pleural surface-based, gross cut-surface, and microscopic margin distances; morphologic features of the adenocarcinomas; microscopic extension distance of beyond gross perimeter of neoplasm; and presence of residual adenocarcinoma in the lobectomy specimen. All staple-line margins in the wedge and lobectomy specimens underwent complete histologic examination. The mean pleural surface-based, gross cut-surface, and microscopic margin distances in wedge resections were 13.1, 4.1, and 2.3 mm, respectively. The mean microscopic wedge resection margin distance was 11 mm smaller than the pleural surface-based measured margin. The mean microscopic lepidic growth beyond the gross perimeter of the neoplasm was 7.4 mm. Fourteen lobectomy specimens (45%) included adenocarcinoma. The mean microscopic wedge resection specimen margin distances in cases with and without residual adenocarcinoma in the lobectomy specimens were 0.7 and 2.4 mm, respectively (P < .001). Incomplete excision may contribute to higher locoregional recurrence rates following limited resection surgery. Two processes affected wedge resection margin distances: stapling-induced parenchymal stretching, resulting in overestimation of pleural surface-based distances, and microscopic extension of adenocarcinoma beyond the gross perimeter of the neoplasm.

Safety and reproducibility of virtual-assisted lung mapping: a multicentre study in Japan†

“…It is thought that sufficient resection margins may have a significant impact on the incidence of local recurrence and, ultimately, patients’ prognosis [19, 20], which used to be the major drawback for sub-lobar resection [21]; however, appropriate patient selection and selection of appropriate procedures are likely to result in a loco-regional recurrence rate equivalent to that of lobectomy [22]. A challenge is to standardize the measurement of surgical margins, for example, the resection margin of deflated versus inflated lungs and the management of staple lines.…”

Lung Cancer: Preoperative Pulmonary Evaluation of the Lung Resection Candidate

“…Another study reviewed the pathology of 31 T1N0M0 lesions that had been diagnosed by wedge resection, which then proceeded to completion lobectomy. 116 They found the average microscopic margin was 2.3 mm and noted microscopic growth beyond the gross perimeter of 7.4 mm. Seventeen of the lobectomy specimens were free of cancer, whereas cancer was found in the other 14.…”

Accelerated Partial Breast Irradiation: Potential Roles following Breast-Conserving Surgery

“…Investigators at William Beaumont Hospital performed a similar study evaluating the amount of disease within one-half low-powered microscopic field of the inked margin on all slides quantifying the linear extent of disease and number of ducts involved by DCIS. 29 They categorized specimens as "least," "intermediate," and "greatest." At 5 years, actuarial local failure increased only marginally, with increasing tumor burden among the three groups with rates of 1%, 3%, and 6%, respectively.…”