Ultra-high-performance concrete (UHPC) is an innovative cementitious composite containing steel fiber reinforcement that can improve the behavior of structural elements thanks to its high strength and improved ductility properties. The mix design that provides these superior properties of UHPC also makes it a high-cost material. For this reason, the use of UHPC in parts where it contributes more significantly to the performance of the structural elements will lower down the costs and reduce the negative environmental effects caused by high cement content. In this preliminary study, the production of normal concrete (NC)-UHPC reinforced concrete (RC) composite beams by wet-on-wet casting was investigated by producing mini-RC beams. In the production of mini-RC beams, normal mortar (NM) and self-compacting mortar (SCM) mixtures were used to represent an NC. The results showed that in the production of NC-UHPC composite beams, the mixtures should have different rheological properties depending on the order of the layers. Increasing the total thickness of the UHPC layer enhanced the initial and yield stiffnesses as well as the peak loads. UHPC layer with thicknesses of 15 mm in tension zone, 30 mm in tension zone, and 15+15 mm in tension+compression zone led to the load-carrying capacity increment ratios of 20%, 34.6%, and 24.3%, respectively. However, increasing the thickness of the UHPC layer in the composite beams, especially more than 15 mm, reduced the ductility ratio and energy absorption capacity. Optimizing the tensile reinforcement ratio in UHPC layers can overcome the drawbacks in the ductility.