What Are Reasons for the Large Gender Differences in the Lethality of Suicidal Acts? An Epidemiological Analysis in Four European Countries

Abstract

BackgroundIn Europe, men have lower rates of attempted suicide compared to women and at the same time a higher rate of completed suicides, indicating major gender differences in lethality of suicidal behaviour. The aim of this study was to analyse the extent to which these gender differences in lethality can be explained by factors such as choice of more lethal methods or lethality differences within the same suicide method or age. In addition, we explored gender differences in the intentionality of suicide attempts.Methods and Findings Methods. Design: Epidemiological study using a combination of self-report and official data. Setting: Mental health care services in four European countries: Germany, Hungary, Ireland, and Portugal. Data basis: Completed suicides derived from official statistics for each country (767 acts, 74.4% male) and assessed suicide attempts excluding habitual intentional self-harm (8,175 acts, 43.2% male). Main Outcome Measures and Data Analysis. We collected data on suicidal acts in eight regions of four European countries participating in the EU-funded “OSPI-Europe”-project (www.ospi-europe.com). We calculated method-specific lethality using the number of completed suicides per method * 100 / (number of completed suicides per method + number of attempted suicides per method). We tested gender differences in the distribution of suicidal acts for significance by using the χ2-test for two-by-two tables. We assessed the effect sizes with phi coefficients (φ). We identified predictors of lethality with a binary logistic regression analysis. Poisson regression analysis examined the contribution of choice of methods and method-specific lethality to gender differences in the lethality of suicidal acts.Findings Main ResultsSuicidal acts (fatal and non-fatal) were 3.4 times more lethal in men than in women (lethality 13.91% (regarding 4106 suicidal acts) versus 4.05% (regarding 4836 suicidal acts)), the difference being significant for the methods hanging, jumping, moving objects, sharp objects and poisoning by substances other than drugs. Median age at time of suicidal behaviour (35–44 years) did not differ between males and females. The overall gender difference in lethality of suicidal behaviour was explained by males choosing more lethal suicide methods (odds ratio (OR) = 2.03; 95% CI = 1.65 to 2.50; p < 0.000001) and additionally, but to a lesser degree, by a higher lethality of suicidal acts for males even within the same method (OR = 1.64; 95% CI = 1.32 to 2.02; p = 0.000005). Results of a regression analysis revealed neither age nor country differences were significant predictors for gender differences in the lethality of suicidal acts. The proportion of serious suicide attempts among all non-fatal suicidal acts with known intentionality (NFSAi) was significantly higher in men (57.1%; 1,207 of 2,115 NFSAi) than in women (48.6%; 1,508 of 3,100 NFSAi) (χ2 = 35.74; p < 0.000001).Main limitations of the studyDue to restrictive data security regulations to ensure anonymity in Ireland, specific a...

Completed Suicide Among Methamphetamine Users: A National Study

“…The overwhelming majority of both sexes used violent means, with hanging predominating. Studies among general populations consistently show that males predominately use violent means and females self‐poisoning (Callanan & Davis, ; Mergl et al, ; Värnik et al., ). It also should be noted that the proportion of hangings in this series (70%) far exceeds the half of completed suicides constituted by hanging in Australia (Australian Bureau of Statistics, ).…”

“…Given these harms, it is not surprising that the mortality rate of regular users is elevated 3-6 times (Callaghan et al, 2012;Degenhardt & Hall, 2012;Singleton, Degenhardt, Hall, & Zabransky, 2009). Moreover, given poor health, and high levels of psychopathology and attempted suicide, we would expect suicide to make a significant contribution to excess mortality.…”

Suicide methods in children and adolescents

“…Firearms and hanging are the most lethal methods based on research from Western countries, with case fatality of 60 and 47.5 %, respectively, as indicated by a recent study [14], followed by jumping from height 31.6 %. Selfpoisoning with pesticides has been also reported as very lethal; a study from rural Sri Lanka presented a great variation of case-fatality of different pesticides with Paraquat being highest (42.7 %) [15].…”

Trends and determinants of suicide in Warangal District Telangana, India: six years retrospective study based on secondary data

“…The present study observation of higher suicide rate among male than compared female is in agreement with other epidemiological studies (Badiye et al, 2014;Chettri et al, 2016;Dervic et al, 2012) reporting 2-3 times higher suicide deaths among males than compared to female counterpart. The gender difference in suicide mortality could be attributed to the difference in preference of more lethal and violent suicide method (Mergl et al, 2015), alcohol abuse and its intoxication at the time of suicide attempt (Menon et al, 2015).…”