What do general practitioners know about ADHD? Attitudes and knowledge among first-contact gatekeepers: systematic narrative review

Abstract

BackgroundAttention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is a common childhood disorder with international prevalence estimates of 5 % in childhood, yet significant evidence exists that far fewer children receive ADHD services. In many countries, ADHD is assessed and diagnosed in specialist mental health or neuro-developmental paediatric clinics, to which referral by General (Family) Practitioners (GPs) is required. In such ‘gatekeeper’ settings, where GPs act as a filter to diagnosis and treatment, GPs may either not recognise potential ADHD cases, or may be reluctant to refer. This study systematically reviews the literature regarding GPs’ views of ADHD in such settings.MethodsA search of nine major databases was conducted, with wide search parameters; 3776 records were initially retrieved. Studies were included if they were from settings where GPs are typically gatekeepers to ADHD services; if they addressed GPs’ ADHD attitudes and knowledge; if methods were clearly described; and if results for GPs were reported separately from those of other health professionals.ResultsFew studies specifically addressed GP attitudes to ADHD. Only 11 papers (10 studies), spanning 2000–2010, met inclusion criteria, predominantly from the UK, Europe and Australia. As studies varied methodologically, findings are reported as a thematic narrative, under the following themes: Recognition rate; ADHD controversy (medicalisation, stigma, labelling); Causes of ADHD; GPs and ADHD diagnosis; GPs and ADHD treatment; GP ADHD training and sources of information; and Age, sex differences in knowledge and attitudes.ConclusionsAcross times and settings, GPs practising in first-contact gatekeeper settings had mixed and often unhelpful attitudes regarding the validity of ADHD as a construct, the role of medication and how parenting contributed to presentation. A paucity of training was identified, alongside a reluctance of GPs to become involved in shared care practice. If access to services is to be improved for possible ADHD cases, there needs to be a focused and collaborative approach to training.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12875-016-0516-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Access to diagnosis, treatment, and supportive services among pharmacotherapy-treated children/adolescents with ADHD in Europe: data from the Caregiver Perspective on Pediatric ADHD survey

“…The UK also differed from other countries as the mean time from observation of symptoms to first doctor visit was shorter than the mean time from first doctor visit to formal ADHD diagnosis, possibly due to the emphasis on primary care in the UK health care system 30. For all other countries, it is interesting to note that the mean time from observing symptoms to the first doctor visit was about two to three times longer than the mean time from the first doctor visit to diagnosis.…”

“I’m just a long history of people rejecting referrals” experiences of young people who fell through the gap between child and adult mental health services

“…This finding has implications for clinical practice, in particular regarding adequate training of GPs in managing common mental health conditions. Other recent research in the UK has identified a lack of GP training in managing young people's emotional distress, suicidality, and ADHD (33)(34)(35).…”

Awareness of ADHD in primary care: stakeholder perspectives

“…Themes and subthemes were identified using an adapted approach of Braun and Clarke's [20] six stage process. While previous literature reviews [18,25] and a pilot study highlighted topics that needed to be explored, the interview schedule was developed in a way that allowed new topics to emerge in an inductive manner, aiming to freely explore the participants' experiences. The analytic process began by transcribing each interview verbatim, shortly after being conducted.…”