Two distinct and sympatric populations of Moorish gecko (Tarentola mauritanica) can be easily distinguished: the diurnal-dark gecko, which mainly lives on trees, and the nocturnal-pale gecko, recognizable on anthropic buildings' walls, especially nearby artificial lights, in order to increase the chances to get preys. Here we hypothesize that this evolutionary splitting was determined by the choice of the anthropogenic niche occurring in a population of Moorish gecko back in the time when Homo sapiens used fire in its settlements, luring insects to positive phototaxis. The frequentation of the new trophic niche created by human through light has increasingly strengthened the distinctive traits in the nocturnal population of geckos, driving sympatric speciation by selection for background matching. We provide empirical evidence supporting this hypothesis, suggesting that the nocturnal-pale geckos split from the diurnal-dark populations due to the innate plastic variation determined by their ability to adjust their skin color and later reinforcement of depigmentation. Our study inaugurates an interesting line of investigation that could shed light on the impact that humankind has on the evolutionary trajectories of non-domesticated species, endowed with adaptive plasticity, functional to the exploration and colonization of the anthropic niche.