What factors facilitate the engagement with flipped classrooms used in the preparation for postgraduate medical membership examinations?

Abstract

BackgroundThe “flipped classroom,” a pedagogical model where typical lecture and homework elements are reversed, is being advocated in medical education to support the teaching of a large curriculum. However, research into the use of this model in postgraduate medical education, which requires the application of acquired knowledge, is limited. The aim of this study was to explore the barriers and facilitators to engagement with the flipped classroom model in preparation for the written element of postgraduate membership examinations.MethodsThree focus groups (n=14) were held between February and June 2016. Participants were drawn from a membership examination preparation course, run by the University of Shef-field. Two of the groups (n=10) involved “students” (public health registrars) while the other focus group (n=4) was held with “tutors” (experienced registrars and consultants). The focus groups were audiorecorded and transcribed verbatim. Transcripts were thematically analyzed by using both predetermined and emergent themes.ResultsKey themes that emerged from the data included variation in learning and teaching styles of individuals as well as the feasibility and flexibility of the overall course design. However, management of students’ expectations was found to be the fundamental factor, which underpinned the engagement.ConclusionThe complex interaction of factors affecting engagement in this study highlights the need to consider the appropriateness of the flipped classroom model. However, this must be balanced by the potential benefits of the approach for delivering a large curriculum. Recognizing the central importance of managing expectations at the outset would be useful when considering this model in postgraduate medical education.

“Online Training Is Great but Human Interaction Is Better”: Training Preferences of VA Interdisciplinary Palliative Care Consult Teams

“…For example, the "flipped classroom" is an approach that could increase engagement, promote relevance, and cultivate the development of a network of learners by integrating asynchronous Webbased informational sessions with synchronous in-person, interactional formational activities. [38][39][40][41] Future research should explore ways to stimulate reciprocity in end-of-life Web-based education and training and develop strategies for cultivating a sense of commitment among trainees to implement the training in their practice settings and function as advocates for the expansion of palliative care system-wide.…”

Student Preferences Impact Outcome of Flipped Classroom in Dental Education: Students Favoring Flipped Classroom Benefited More

“…There are also barriers that impair the engagement of students in the flipped classroom. Jesurasa and colleagues reported that the design of the flipped classroom, such as the degree to which the classroom is flipped, the challenges to acquiring fundamental knowledge, limitation of larger class sizes, teaching styles, and students' expectation of the instructors, may all have an effect on students' interest in the flipped classroom [12]. It was reported that students who favored traditional lectures over the flipped classroom thought the flipped classroom encouraged rushed learning, and made them feel behind and inadequate [13].…”

Flipping Online Learning in Public Health Graduate Education

“…This study findings reported here indicate that the flipped classroom approach, which is increasingly advocated for in medical education, can have positive impact on learning outcomes and experiences in the context of online graduate-level public health education (Jesurasa, Mackenzie, Jordan, & Goyder, 2017;Merzel, Halkitis, & Healton, 2017). To quote one of the students, "THIS [emphasis original] is how a graduate level course should be taught."…”