What happens when the doctor denies a patient’s request? A qualitative interview study among general practitioners in Norway

Abstract

ObjectiveTo explore general practitioners (GPs’) experiences from consultations when a patient’s request is denied, and outcomes of such incidents.Design and participantsWe conducted a qualitative study with semi-structured individual interviews with six GPs in Norway. We asked them to tell about experiences from specific encounters where they had refused a patient’s request. The texts were analysed with Systematic Text Condensation, a method for thematic cross-case analysis.Main outcome measuresAccounts of experiences from consultations when GPs refused their patients’ requests.ResultsSubjects of dispute included clinical topics like investigation and treatment, certification regarding welfare benefits and medico-legal issues, and administrative matters. The arguments took different paths, sometimes settled by reaching common ground but more often as unresolved disagreement with anger or irritation from the patient, sometimes with open hostility and violence. The aftermath and outcomes of these disputes lead to strong emotional impact where the doctors reflected upon the incidents and sometimes regretted their handling of the consultation. Some long-standing and close patient–doctor relationships were injured or came to an end.ConclusionsThe price for denying a patient’s request may be high, and GPs find themselves uncomfortable in such encounters. Skills pertaining to this particular challenge could be improved though education and training, drawing attention to negotiation of potential conflicts. Also, the notion that doctors have a professional commitment to his or her own autonomy and to society should be restored, through increased emphasis on core professional ethics in medical education at all levels.

Emotional Responses to Suicidal Patients: Factor Structure, Construct, and Predictive Validity of the Therapist Response Questionnaire-Suicide Form

“…Therefore, these intense reactions may alert a clinician to patient suicide risk independent of overtly evident risk factors such as declared suicidal intent, reported access to means, and so on. At the same time, negative emotional responses may result in less empathic communication, avoidance, and unwitting rejection of the patient ( 67 – 69 ) which are liable to damage the therapeutic alliance ( 70 ). Thus, further research is needed to elucidate the mechanisms by which clinicians’ negative emotional responses are associated with patients’ subsequent suicidal outcomes.…”

Difficult Patient Encounters: Assessing Pediatric Residents' Communication Skills Training Needs

“…Residents reported wide variation in level of satisfaction with most difficult encounter types, with the exception of encounters with unfocused parental historians or breaking bad news, which less than 25% found to be dissatisfying or highly dissatisfying. Dissatisfaction and anxiety are important to note, as research has shown that this can affect provider wellness, with physicians experiencing a range of emotional and physical reactions, including abdominal pain, exhaustion and fear after they have denied a patient’s request [ 23 ]. Furthermore, ambivalence and decisional conflict can cause psychological discomfort [ 24 ].…”

The dilemma of repeat weak opioid prescriptions – experiences from swedish GPs

“…According to Bendtsen & Hensing, prescribing opioides gives rise to discomfort and conflicting feelings, not only within the doctor him or herself, but also between the doctor and the patient or between colleagues, and it can give rise to an atmosphere characterised by conflicts, guilt and even anxiety [ 17 ]. Refusing a patient’s request for investigation, treatment, certification for welfare benefits or administrative matters often seem to lead to disagreements between the patient and the doctor, according to a Norwegian study [ 25 ]. This may have strong emotional impact for the doctor and could even mean the end of a long-lasting patient-doctor relationship.…”