“…In TiS 3 , the Ti 2p 3/2 and 2p 1/2 core level binding energies are 455.9 and 461.9 eV, respectively, and for the ZrS 3 , the Zr 3p 3/2 and 3p 1/2 binding energies are 332.1 and 345.7 eV. These values are consistent with previous XPS measurements on TiS 3 ,,,− and ZrS 3 . − Because of the complication just mentioned above and because TiS 3 and ZrS 3 are strongly n-type, using these XPS binding energies is an overestimate of the energy needed to place E F in the XAS S 2p, Zr 3p, and Ti 2p edges, so discrepancies are addressed by using the onset edges observed in XAS and the Ca 2p edges from the CaCO 3 present in the epoxy as a reference in the case of ZrS 3 . Because both TiS 3 ,,− ,, and ZrS 3 , are strongly n-type materials, with the distance from the valence band to the Fermi level approximately equal to the band gap, , the onset of states in XAS should occur directly at E f .…”