What is an Engineer? Implications of Elementary School Student Conceptions for Engineering Education

Abstract

BACKGROUNDResearch in engineering education tends to focus on students' factual knowledge about engineering, their interests and attitudes, and on students' conceptions of the engineer and the relation to curriculum development. Thus, it is essential to expand our understanding of students' conceptions about the engineer phenomenon as the foundation for informing STEM education standards and curriculum. PURPOSE (HYPOTHESIS)The purpose of this study was to investigate students' conceptions about engineers specifically: (1) What are elementary school students' conceptions of an engineer? (2) How might students' conceptions vary by grade level, gender, and community setting? (3) What are implications of students' conceptions for engineering education? DESIGN/METHODThis study was descriptive in nature and reflected a cross-age design involving the collection of qualitative data from about 400 Grade 1 through 5 students from urban and suburban schools located in the Midwest, United States. Data were analyzed using content analysis and statistical testing. RESULTSStudents conceptualized an engineer as a mechanic, laborer, and technician. Students' conceptions entailed the engineer fixing, building, or making and using vehicles, engines, and tools. Students' conceptions were relatively consistent across urban and suburban school communities with the exceptions that laborer was more common among urban students and technician was more common among suburban students. More than half of the students who drew a person drew male engineers. CONCLUSIONSA framework for organizing and interpreting students' conceptions is presented. Curricular recommendations and implications are made that build on students' conceptions and reinforce connections between national standards and the engineer concept.

Investigating the impact of pedagogical agent gender matching and learner choice on learning outcomes and perceptions

“…However, an important finding from Experiment 1 is that female students' perception of instruction can be positively impacted when provided a same-gendered agent; females had higher program ratings when the APA matched their gender than when a male agent was presented. Female students may perceive the program using a same-gendered agent more favorably than when using opposite-gendered agents because of gender stereotypes concerning women in engineering (Byrne, 1993;Capobianco, Diefes-Dux, Mena, & Weller, 2011;Johnson, Ozogul, Moreno, & Reisslein, 2013;Knight & Cunningham, 2004). The use of a peer-model to explain engineering problem-solving to female students may increase the female learners' feelings of self-efficacy toward engineering.…”

Engineering Identity Implications on the Retention of Black Women in the Engineering Industry

“…The 0.72% that remain engaged perhaps hold the key to understanding the mechanisms necessary to pursuing a satisfying and lengthy career in engineering. The identity framework has proven to be successful in understanding engagement throughout the engineering learning life cycle, K-16 and the workplace 22,23,7 ; however, it has been limited to race or gender or engineering. The recommendation is to push the boundaries further, to look at the complexities that exist at the intersection of race, gender, and engineering identities.…”

The Humanistic Side of Engineering: Considering Social Science and Humanities Dimensions of Engineering in Education and Research

“…However, it is unclear if this is because engineering activities provide a fun break from students' normal classroom activities, or because they are truly motivated by the opportunities to engineer. Results from various studies using the Draw an Engineer Test illustrate many naïve perceptions young students have and how engineering curricula and interventions change these perceptions (Capobianco, Diefes-Dux, Mena, & Weller, 2011;Knight & Cunningham, 2004). However, there is little research that investigates the root cause of these shifts in attitudes, beliefs, and perceptions.…”