What Is Genealogy? Philosophy, Education, Motivations and Future Prospects

Abstract

This article is a first attempt to generate discussion and academic analysis of the modus operandi of genealogy and genealogists. Genealogy is on the verge of becoming a recognised profession and an academic discipline, with one or more qualification routes. This article summarises the author's philosophy, motivations and experiences in establishing educational/training courses and qualifications in a University context. Definitions of genealogy and related concepts are discussed, in the light of an epistemological analysis. Such philosophical considerations are rarely discussed among professional genealogists. It is hoped this article will be a stimulus to more enlightened debate of the epistemological and philosophical bases of family history-type genealogy. There is also a dearth of research into the motivations of amateur and professional genealogists, and almost no scholarly scrutiny of genealogy as an academic discipline. Nor can it be dismissed as "a branch of history"; genealogy and history are related but separate disciplines with overlapping skills-sets.

Citizen science at the roots and as the future of forensic genetic genealogy

“…This implies that forensic science is in a “‘liminal space’ which are transitional and transformative states in which the values and norms of one stage have been left behind and the values and norms of the later stage have not yet been reached” (Derksen, 2010: 221). Within this liminal space, new norms, values, and consensus about the technology need to be created because genealogy “is on the verge of becoming a recognised profession and an academic discipline” (Durie, 2017: 1).…”

Ethical Dilemmas and Family History: A Psychological Approach

“…Even in situations where individuals hire a professional genealogist to investigate their ancestral pasts, clients can become extremely upset when findings do not meet their expectations, as noted by Durie (2017).…”

Using genetic genealogy databases in missing persons cases and to develop suspect leads in violent crimes

“…Genealogy is largely conducted as a hobby but some hobbyists turn professional and charge for their services, and there are now some university courses which offer genealogical training. [118] There has been a long-standing debate within the genealogical community about whether or not professional genealogists should be accredited, and there is no consensus. Although there are some professional organisations, they have limited powers to enforce standards, and there are many professional practitioners who do not belong to any organisation.…”